Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE HEAD OF the Irish Kidney Association has said the government is doing “the bare minimum” to improve organ donor rates in the country.
CEO Mark Murphy said the approach of Health Minister James Reilly “hasn’t been good enough” and criticised the government’s approach to organ donation, saying that “Ireland was the last country to bring in legislation [regarding organ donation] and was forced to do it.”
He is also sceptical of the government’s plans to legislate for opt-out organ donation, describing it as “the last thing on the agenda that needs to be done”, before adding that “it doesn’t need to be done at all in my view. I see the consent issue as a distraction”.
While Minister Reilly was unavailable for comment, a spokesman from the Department of Health said that changing the system of consent is “just one aspect in a package of measures that will be required to increase organ donation rates”.
“In this regard, the Department… is considering what practices and organisational changes, along with the change to the consent system, could further improve donation rates in this country,” the spokesperson said.
Opt-out organ donation is where consent for donations after death is presumed, unless someone explicitly states that they do not wish to be a donor. Currently, where a potential donor is identified, their family is asked for consent for donation. The system being proposed is a ‘soft’ opt-out system, whereby organs would not be removed against the wishes of the next of kin.
The Department of Heath asked for public consultation on the issue in July. Individuals and groups were asked to submit their views on opt-out by 23 September.
Murphy claims that opt-out is ineffective, and has had little impact on donor rates in counties where it has been brought in, saying that “it is not used in practise” and that opt-out could actually lead to problems, citing the negative reaction to presumed consent laws introduced in Brazil where the law was repealed following a public backlash against organ donation.
However, it should be noted that this was a ‘hard’ opt-out system, which did not require family consent.
“It’s the practice that changes things,” said Murphy.
Changing consent by law doesn’t change anything. In Europe they are all seeking the consent of the next of kin, presuming it is impossible. You cannot presume something of a bereaved family.
Regarding what could be done instead of opt-out to increase donor rates, Murphy identified donor coordinators, those responsible for seeking consent from the families, as being crucial, as well as the establishment of an organ donor registry of those who have given consent.
It’s all about the way you ask. It is much stronger if a donor coordinator can go to a registry, and see that they said yes, and then go to the family and say that we’re looking for you to salute their wish to donate organs after their death.
The spokesman from the Department of Health stated that:
We will legislate to change the organ donation to an opt-out system for organ transplantation, rather than an opt in system so as to improve the availability of organs for patients in desperate need. The overall objective is to increase organ availability and to enhance the efficiency and accessibility of transplantation systems.
They also added that the Department plans to host a focused workshop on the findings of the consultation, which will “inform the next steps in the legislative process”.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
I suppose the CIA will blame the Russians and use it to attack the Trump administration.
@Tommy: Wikileaks didn’t get this info by themselves. So as such it was supplied to them. And it is well known that Assange and Wikileaks have a cosy relationship with the FSB.
@Mick Jordan: RED THUMB
If you wrap your phone in tinfoil you’re safe enough
@Alan b..: You used to be able to just put it in a microwave for a minute on full power but even the microwaves are watching us now….
So basically if you’ve a seven year old IPhone and if the CIA get their hands in it they might be able to feck about with it… Considering the new IPhone was rooted about a month after it was released I’d be more worried if the most powerful security agency on earth couldn’t do what wikileaks are saying they can do…
Do you have children ? People who maintain that having access to your living room, or bedroom for that mater, via TV, Laptop etc. even when turned off, is harmless and in safe hands should watch following short clip.
https://www.facebook.com/DeprogramYourself/videos/1737632829889657/
@Pat O’Dwyer: frank is that you?
if the shit is going down wouldn’t you hope the special forces. CIA. GCHQ or the garda.lol can track a mobile phone and hack it to use camera and mic. it’s a mobile device it is NOT secure so don’t believe it to be and get all offended that the government in an attempt to keep us safe might hack a phone.
have your say