Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
Updated 11.39pm
THE FORMER GARDA Commissioner Martin Callinan wrote to the Department of Justice about recordings of calls at garda stations more than two weeks ago, RTÉ has reported.
Callinan is reported to have sent a letter to the Secretary General of the department asking that the Minister of Justice be made aware of the details of the recordings.
The letter is dated 1o March 2014 and was couriered over to the department.
Tonight, a spokesperson for Minister Alan Shatter told TheJournal.ie he only received this letter this morning. The spokesperson was unable to confirm if this was before or after Callinan resigned just before 10am.
The letter, entitled “Recordings of Telephone Conversations made and retained in Garda Stations”, which has been seen by RTÉ News, says the initial recording systems were put in place in the 1980s.
Informed yesterday
A government spokesperson said Shatter was told yesterday of the details that have emerged today of phonecalls in and out of a large number of garda stations being recorded.
This is after the Taoiseach said he was told, on Sunday at 6pm.
Enda Kenny told the Dáil today that the Government had received information of tape recordings in “many garda stations” dating back to the 1980s.
He said he was made aware of the information on Sunday by the Attorney General and spent all day yesterday and last night checking the “validity and veracity of the information”.
The Government said it had learned that system had been in place “for many years” up until November of last year at “a large number of Garda stations” where “incoming and outgoing calls were taped and recorded”.
Speaking earlier this evening, Data Protection Commissioner Billy Hawkes said he had been made aware of the issue by An Garda Siochána “three or four days ago”.
Letter
Speaking on tonight’s 9 o’clock News, RTÉ Crime Correspondent Paul Reynolds, who has seen the letter, said it was three pages long and had been couriered over to the Department of Justice on 10 March.
Reynolds said that the former Commissioner’s letter states that the Attorney General was informed of the issue in November of last year.
Shatter’s spokesperson maintained this evening that the Minister was first given the letter today.
According to RTÉ, the recording systems were first set up in the 1980s to record not just 999 calls but also bomb threats and other messages to the gardaí.
The letter also reportedly says that the system was updated in the 1990s with dictaphones and then again updated in 2008. Over 2,500 tapes are said to be in existence, some of which are now ‘mouldy’ and not playable.
A Garda spokesperson told TheJournal.ie tonight that: “In accordance Garda Siochána Act 2005, the Interim Garda Commissioner will provide a report on the matter to the Minister”.
The spokesperson said Noirín O’Sullivan was “taking a personal interest in the matter to ensure it is fully addressed”.
Data Commissioner
Speaking earlier this evening, Data Protection Commissioner Billy Hawkes said that as far as his office was aware, most gardaí would not have been aware that the calls were being recorded, and that it appeared the recording system had been built into their phone network.
Speaking on Today FM’s The Last Word, he said he had been made aware of the matter by the force within the last three or four days and asked for advice on what should happen in such circumstances.
“The key thing for us is that the practice was no longer there,” Hawkes said.
“Our main focus is stopping things happening that shouldn’t be happening.”
Hawkes said: “There seems to have been limited awareness that this was going on at all and therefore limited use of such material”.
It seems it was built into the phone system that was there, the phone system that the gardaí had.
Report
Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams tonight said that it is was credible that the Minister for Justice was unaware of last June’s Ombudsman’s report which details the illegal Garda practice of recording incoming and outgoing calls from stations.
The Garda Ombudsman (GSOC) report from last year criticised the recordings of calls in 2010. Sources close to Shatter say he was not aware of this report and that GSOC was not obligated to notify the minister of its existence.
Adams tonight called on the Taoiseach and the Minister for Justice to come into the Dáil and give a full account of what the Government knew, and when.
The Sinn Féin leader said:
The Garda Ombudsman report published last June clearly identifies the Garda practice of recording outgoing and incoming calls.
At that time the Ombudsman said that the ‘Garda Commissioner may wish to re-evaluate his practise regarding the recording of such calls.’
The Ombudsman’s report would have been sent to the Garda Commissioner and to the Department of Justice.
It is not credible that the Minister for Justice was unaware of this or that he was not told of Ombudsman’s concern.
John Redmond of representative body the Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors said tonight he was “very surprised” at the revelations that phonecalls to garda stations were being recorded.
Asked on tonight’s Prime Time whether he thought recent problems were indicative of a cultural problem within the force, Redmond said:
I suppose several would say there is a cultural problem. Let’s have a look at it. Let’s explore and examine it.
The Minister intends to deal with the questions arising out of today’s developments during a statement in the Dáil tomorrow morning.
The house is due to spend most of the day debating the report of the Garda Inspectorate into the penalty points controversy but matters which have emerged today are likely to dominate.
Additional reporting from Daragh Brophy and Hugh O’Connell. First posted at 8.50pm.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
I work with Caroline and how she has conducted herself through these terrible events is very admirable. Her and her family’s determination to get justice despite their grief and the awful circumstances of Michael’s death shows such strength of character. I hope they uncover the whole truth. RIP Michael Dwyer.
can’t argue with any of this, and i feel very sorry for her and the family. but this article does nothing to address what he was doing in bolivia. recession doesn’t lead to many people seeking their fortune in latin america with right wing europeans. my guess is (and yes it’s a guess), he was bored with ireland, and was drawn in by a charismatic person with ideas of revolution and adventure and the like. won’t be the first or last to do this, and not always a bad thing necessarily. think of irish poeple who fought in spanish civil war. and by the way, whatever the circumstances of him being there, it bears all the hall-marks of extra-judicial killing.
Bolivia of all places to go..
Australia, America or Canada would probably have being safer…
Hopefully the truth will come out,
But it’s very doubtful it will….
ODwyer was murdered by the Bolivian government in an attempt to undermine rebels seeking independence in that region of Bolivia. They tried to make it look like he was an IRA mercenary along with others from the former russian block and eastern europe to justify their actions in the region.
Many know of his story of security courses that fell through in Europe and the US and for some reason he ended up doing some form of training in Bolivia..but he is an innocent man an he was murdered!
My condolences to Michael’s family. I heard his parents speak on radio one morning a few years back and they struck me as very reasoned, decent people who just wanted to find out what happened to their beloved son. I wish the armchair detectives would just zip it and let them get on with their heartbreaking quest. I cannot imagine their pain and the loss they face every day. I can only wish them strength and success and hope that they find the truth. There but for the grace of god…
Wasn’t he part of a group out to murder the Bolivian president? Good job their plans were foiled.
Dave, there is no proof of that at all .
Did he have any connection with the dodgy mercenary “commander” in Louth? Well covered in the Pheonix.
Greg I worked with Caroline too and I have no doubt others reading this may have a personal connection with Caroline or some other family members. Please show some respect. Those who don’t know the fact please stop assuming that you do.
But the family don’t know the facts either, nor do any of the people who support the idea that he was innocent.
I agree people shouldn’t so easily make assumptions, but that goes for both sides!
Did this guy do any ‘Bodyguard’ courses? Any ‘Close Protection’ courses? Or ‘Hostile Environment Awareness Training’ courses or the like? The ones that say learn to be a bodyguard in a weekend, 4 days, etc.
If so chances are is that he duped into a ‘job’ abroad. Unfortunately it has happened many times.
My condolences to his family.
I knew this guy in college in Galway. He was very mannerly . He worked in halo nightclub doing security and in Dunnes in the deli for a short period . He was very pleasant and friendly .
I’ve spent time in Bolivia and it can be difficult just to get the simplest of things done. Can’t imagine what this family have had to go through.
Did he have any connection with the dodgy “mercenary commander” in Louth. Well documented in the Pheonix magazine.
have your say