We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Skip to 28 seconds in the video above for the controversial comments
IF YOU THOUGHT Simon Cowell’s comments to X Factor contestants could be cutting, spare a thought for the participants in the show’s New Zealand offshoot.
Two judges on X Factor NZ, singers Natalia Kills and her husband Willy Moon, have been fired amid claims they bullied contestant Joe Irvine over the suggestion he looked like Moon.
Where it all began
Following Irvine’s performance on the show, Kills said to him:
“As an artist who respects creative integrity and intellectual property, I am disgusted at how much you’ve copied my husband. From the hair to the suit, do you not have any value or respect for originality? You’re a laughing stock. It’s cheesy, it’s disgusting. I personally found it absolutely artistically atrocious.
In response, Irvine asked her: “But don’t you copy Cleopatra?”
“I am embarrassed to be sitting here in your presence having to even dignify you with an answer of my opinion,” she replied.
“Thank you Natalia, you’re beautiful,” said Irvine.
Later, Kills told him:
You make me sick, It’s absolutely disgusting. You have no identity. I can’t stand it. I’m ashamed to be here.
Her husband Will Moon told Irvine:
To me it just feels a bit cheap and absurd to me. It’s like Norman Bates dressing up in his mother’s clothing, it’s just a little bit creepy and I feel that you’re going to stitch someone’s skin to your face and then kill everybody in the audience.
A baffled-looking Irvine told him: ”I think I look really good.”
Former All Saints member Melanie Blatt is one of the judges, and told Irvine not to listen to Kills and Moon’s comments.
In the wake of the duo’s controversial critique, social media sites have been ablaze with reaction – much of it directed at Kills. A Boycott the X-Factor New Zealand Facebook site has been set up.
New Zealand on Air, which funded the country’s X Factor series, encouraged upset viewers to complain to Mediaworks:
Goodbye to you
The morning after the show, Mediaworks announced that both Kills and Moon were being given the chop, describing them as “no longer suitable to judge the X Factor”.
Mediaworks CEO, Mark Weldon, described the couple’s comments as “completely unacceptable”.
While the judges on X Factor are expected to provide critiques of performances, we will not tolerate such destructive tirades from any of the judges.
We no longer have confidence that Kills and Moon are the right people to perform the role of The X Factor judges, and they will leave the show, effective immediately.
FremantleMedia Australia’s Director of Programming, Jonathon Summerhayes, said they are “appalled at the very poor judgement and intention shown by Natalia Kills and Willy Moon”.
We 100% support TV3 and MediaWorks in their decision to remove them. The X Factor does not tolerate the behavior they displayed last night.
Two new judges will be announced before next week’s show.
What did Kills and Moon have to say for themselves?
Kills, a Bradford, England-born musician whose most recent album was called Trouble, tweeted:
Her husband only had this to say (McLaren was the former Sex Pistols manager and always good for a controversial quote):
Moon is a New Zealander best-known for having his song ‘Yeah Yeah’ featured on a 2012 Apple iPod commercial.
Their fellow judges commented:
melanie blatt / TwitterIve tried to keep my cool and stay professional but really @nataliakills ? Sorry love , you're a twat https://t.co/l2lIE21G99
— melanie blatt (@melblatt) March 15, 2015
Stan Walker / Twitter@NataliaKills U think its alright 2 champion urself in ur disgusting actions with no remorse 4 being a bully. Wake up man & humble urself.
— Stan Walker (@1stanwalker) March 15, 2015
Stan Walker / TwitterEveryone, even tho she is in the wrong, 2 wrongs dont make a right, dont attack her & lower urselves 2 be like that. This is out of control!
— Stan Walker (@1stanwalker) March 15, 2015
And as for Irvine?
Light relief
Amid the insults, the furore also lead to these reactions:
What do you make of what the judges said? Tell us in the comments below.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
I like the determination of the owner!
Great Idea…new for here….
Well done to all involved. Can’t believe RTE aren’t showing any of this. Great story.
Hope the last leg goes well for him. We’ll be there waiting! (May venture up this evening for the atmosphere!)
A lot of people have criticised this guy for spending silly money on a crazy idea! But from a business perspective this has been a master stroke! The free advertising this guy has generated couldn’t be bought! People will be “Dying” to stay there when its complete! !
“It wasn’t all plane sailing”
Fair play to him.
It’s not easy to overcome all the red tape and bureaucracy that was put in his way.
Boaty McPlaneface!
Are the wings going to be put back on when it’s in place?
Fair play to someone for making a go of a thing but isn’t glamping essentially camping in permanent structures? So sort of non camping camping like a chalet resort with a special name on it? It’s “put a fancy name on and whack the prices up”-ery.
Well done to all and the best of luck ✈️
This story is getting serious airtime! I wonder how much the owner is paying the Journal?
Q, sleep time..
Hi Rob, I think the journal are posting about this because it gets alot of “clicks” so the more clicks the better for the journal.
Lad your a fair clown..
I hope it takes off for him.
They Deirdre Whitney sounds like a right see you next tuesday
Should be a runaway success.
Real spell caster revives !
Life without my husband was a real mess for me and my children,What on Earth will i do to thank Dr BALOGUN for his help? he is wonderful and has a good heart. He is like a God on Earth and i really do not know what to do to thank him for helping me regain my husbands love back with his spell. months ago my husband told me it was over between us and he let me and our children without saying a word, i did all i could to stop him because his mind was made up. few months later my friend told me how DR BALOGUN helped her with his spell,I love my husband so much that i would give up every thing for him, so i contacted Dr BALOGUN to also help me with his spell and he responded saying that he will help me with his spell that I should clam down and i will see result within 12 to 16 hours Today, i am so glad that everything happened just as Dr BALOGUN said, my husband will came back to me within 12 to 16 hours on his knees begging me to forgive him and I accepted him back into my life. Do you need help are you worried about your ex husband or your boyfriend left you for another,here is Dr BALOGUN he is a real and genuine spell caster contact him for help via email:
balogunsolutiontemple@gmail.com
REGARD FROM,
Dr BALOGUN
20,000 for a boeng ??? Bargain !!!!
I would be very wary of being near, or getting into, any ex-Transaero aircraft given that Transaero lied to the British authorities following the Russian state sponsored assassination of Alexander Litvinenko, an ex KGB agent and critic of Vladimir Putin. It turned out the two Russian suspects in Mr Litvinenko’s murder travelled several times on Transaero aircraft between Moscow and London carrying quantities of Plonium 210, the radioactive substance used to kill him in a London restaurant. When the British authorities asked Transaero to test their aircraft for radioactive contamination Transaero said they had and they were all clear. However, when the Metropolitan Police impounded a Transaero aircraft at Heathrow as part of their investigation into Mr Litvinenko’s murder, they found it to be contaminated with the substance used to kill him. I, for one, would not get into a Transaero aircraft, decommissioned or otherwise.
Have model of same to scale.beautiful piece
have your say