After the fall: How TV and film coped with the loss of the Twin Towers image

The fall of the WTC left many TV and film producers with difficult decisions: should they remove any images of them, or leave them intact?

ONE OF THE reasons that the fall of the World Trade Centre is such a potent and lingering symbol is because of how they dominate so many depictions of the New York skyline.

As one of the best-known vistas in the world, the rooftops of Manhattan were shown in countless TV series and films – leaving many with some delicate decisions to make in the aftermath of the attacks, choosing whether to retrospectively edit scenes featuring the towers’ image.

Here’s a selection of some of the depictions of the Twin Towers in popular culture – where some images were later removed, while others continue to live on screens around the world.

The Simpsons

Previous 1 / 9Next

The Simpsons
The Simpsons memorably visited New York in 1997, when Homer had to collect his car - left by Barney Gumble at the foot of the towers. Needing to visit the bathroom, he ascended up the entirety of one tower - only to find it out of order, and having to dash to the summit of the second. Fox decided not to withdraw the episode from circulation, though many US affiliates still decline to air it while others show it with many WTC references - though it airs regularly worldwide, including on RTÉ. Fox's NYC affiliate aired the entire show, uncensored, within a fortnight of 9/11.
Family Guy
Though Family Guy adopts the usual cartoon formula of ensuring its characters never age, newer episodes have acknowledged the chain of events in real life. In a 2000 episode Peter Griffin jumps off one building as part of a musical number - while in 2002, a panoramic tour of New York (drawn up before 9/11) digitally altered the buildings to make them look more generic, and less like the WTC buildings. In 2008, the Griffins visited Ground Zero on a road trip - causing Peter to gasp, "Wow, so this is where the first guy got AIDS."
Sex And The City
The first four series (of six) of the TV serialisation of Candice Bushnall's novel include a depiction of the World Trade Centre behind Sarah Jessica Parker's name. For series 5 and 6, aired after 9/11, the image was instead replaced with a shot of the Empire State Building. The first episode filmed after the attacks was an indirect tribute to the city, placing heavy focus on some of the city's defining cultural aspects.
The Sopranos
The Sopranos followed its HBO stablemate's lead in changing its theme. For the first three series, an image of the WTC could be seen in the reflection of Tony Soprano's mirror during the opening credits. From series 4, it had been replaced with a general Manhattan skyline - while Tony made reference to the attacks in subsequent on-screen dialogue.
Friends
The New York-based sitcom featured many shots of the Twin Towers between scenes - giving producers a difficult choice to make. Title cards had been changed between series anyway, but it was decided that later episodes would still include shots across the Towers, though not finishing on them. The final episode, aired in 2004, made a point of featuring one sequence which ended on a lingering shot of the WTC.
The West Wing
The 9/11 attacks occurred 19 days before the third series of The West Wing was due to air. Feeling that the initial plotline - about President Josiah Bartlet's personal illness - was out of touch with the new climate, writer Aaron Sorkin write and produced a special non-sequential episode 'Isaac and Ishmael' responding to Islamic terrorism. In it, the fictional White House is under lockdown fearing a potential follow-up attack, while senior staffers discuss the motivation of Islamic terrorism with visiting teenagers. The episode aired in the slot originally set aside for the series premiere, and was widely lauded for its mature approach to sensitive subjects.
Spider-man
One of the first teaser posters for the 2002 film Spider-Man - released before 9/11, naturally - included a small image of the Twin Towers being reflected in Peter Parker's eyes. The poster had only been issued days before the attacks, and was withdrawn after them - making the poster a collector's item. A similar trailer showed Spidey weaving a web between the towers to capture a helicopter carrying two absconding criminals - but that trailer, too, was removed. (Other images of the Towers reflected in Spidey's eyes, in the movie itself, were left intact.)
The Toxic Avenger IV
Not a very high-profile example - and one that sits uneasily among the rest of this collection - but one that became oddly symbolic to New Yorkers. This film was one of the first to get a major premiere after 9/11, and unlike other producers who chose to doctor images of the Twin Towers out of their work, producer Lloyd Kaufman decided to leave his intact - with audiences reportedly whooping in delight when the images were first shown.
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
"There were no jobs available for a man in the foetal position under his desk, crying." With those lines, The Daily Show's Jon Stewart returned to air, two weeks after the attacks had forced him into a 9-show hiatus. In a monologue which often descended into tears, the revered satirist admitted: "Television is nothing if not redundant… we do it so we can drain our hearts of whatever abscess is in them… I'm sure we're getting right under the wire before the cast of Survivor comes in." Though the attacks had been horrific, he said, the US's response was the embodiment of Martin Luther King's dream to judge people on their character. "That's why we've already won… they can't shut that down." His monologue closed with the admission that the view from his apartment had formerly been of the WTC: now it was of the Statue of Liberty. "You can't beat that," Stewart sniffed. Watch the video here.

here." title="">

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...

A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Learn More Support The Journal

9/11

Author

Gavan Reilly

View 14 comments

Send Tip or Correction

14 Comments

Andrew Bernos 14y

Install the app to use these features.

Mute Andrew Bernos

Favourite Andrew Bernos

Sep 10th 2011, 11:01 PM

Personally I feel the Towers should not be edited out of older media. They stood then and should continue as a symbol.

Ordinary Joe 14y

Mute Ordinary Joe

Favourite Ordinary Joe

Sep 10th 2011, 11:21 PM

I agree!

pagan 13y

Mute pagan

Favourite pagan

Sep 10th 2011, 7:15 PM

Still weird hearing and looking at footage of 9/11.I still know what i was doing and where i was on that day 10yrs ago.This is our JFK moment.Everybody knows were they were on that fatal day.

neuromancer 14y

Mute neuromancer

Favourite neuromancer

Sep 10th 2011, 9:32 PM

In the TV show Fringe, the series storylines parallel universes. In one of the universes, ours, the towers are not there. But in the other universe they still stand.

The reason behind that is to show that different decisions were made by people which account for them still standing, in the alternate universe.

I like how they added the towers into the storylines, and gives depth to the series too.

Phil Mc Donald 14y

Mute Phil Mc Donald

Favourite Phil Mc Donald

Sep 10th 2011, 10:10 PM

Love that episode of The Simpsons. Saw it in Nov’97, one week before I went to New York for the 1st & only time. Spent a few hours in the North Tower to get some shots of Manhattan in the day & night, always think of the staff I spoke to that day who worked in the observation deck and wonder were they there 4 years later…

Spacer85 14y

Mute Spacer85

Favourite Spacer85

Sep 11th 2011, 12:31 AM

mountain dew or crab juice?

jackass ireland 14y

Mute jackass ireland

Favourite jackass ireland

Sep 10th 2011, 10:09 PM

Great piece. Thanks Journal people.

Toast Rack 14y

Mute Toast Rack

Favourite Toast Rack

Sep 10th 2011, 9:54 PM

Interesting piece.

Sep 10th 2011, 10:04 PM

Remember the movie A.I? They visited New York thousands of years in the future, most of Manhattan is destroyed by the polar ice cap but the towers still stood. Very creepy as the movie came out soon after 9/11 (I think)

Stephen G 13y

Mute Stephen G

Favourite Stephen G

Sep 11th 2011, 12:33 AM

For me, the most prominent thing in that Simpsons episode was the crab juice!

Stephen Travers 14y

Mute Stephen Travers

Favourite Stephen Travers

Sep 11th 2011, 9:01 AM

Evil succeeded in knocking The Twin Towers but, inadvertently, built an eternal monument to the spirit and courage of The American People.

angryzes 14y

Mute angryzes

Favourite angryzes

Sep 11th 2011, 10:43 AM

You forgot Fight Club where they put entire NY down.

Sep 11th 2011, 10:44 AM

To journal.ie, on iPhone and iPad I cannot see full text of picture description.

Sep 11th 2011, 10:45 AM

I am talking about latest version of the app of course.

Defamation

Damaging the good reputation of someone, slander, or libel.
Racism or Hate speech

An attack on an individual or group based on religion, race, gender, or beliefs.
Trolling or Off-topic

An attempt to derail the discussion.
Inappropriate language

Profanity, obscenity, vulgarity, or slurs.
Spam

Advertising, phishing, scamming, bots, or repetitive posts.
Other