Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
First published 6 March
IT IS A NIGHTMARE scenario: a convicted armed robber, fresh out on parole, enters a jewellery shop and stabs the owner to death, badly injuring his wife.
At a backpackers’ party, a man with a criminal record viciously attacks two housemates.
A woman is taken, raped and killed by a man with a string of convictions.
Murder in Melbourne
Many Irish people have flocked to Melbourne in Australia to start a new life. But for Dermot and Bridget O’Toole, David Greene and Jill Meagher, their time abroad turned to tragedy.
Now the murders of three Irish people living in Melbourne between 2012 and 2013, and their families’ fight for justice, is explored in a new RTÉ documentary due to be broadcast on Monday night.
The documentary also looks at the parole system in Victoria to examine its role in these otherwise unrelated murders.
Dublin couple Dermot and Bridget O’Toole (pictured above, with their sons) moved to Melbourne in 1972. ”We just fell in love with it,” recalled Bridget.
They went on to have three children, and the family was a tight unit. They moved to Hastings in 1981, where Dermot opened a shop called The Jewel Shed.
“We were exceptionally happy,” said Bridget, who worked with her husband in the shop. “They were the perfect couple,” said a family friend.
But in July 2013, a man came into the shop during the day, accompanied by his girlfriend and child.
After he looked at the jewellery, he wiped his fingerprints off the counter and door.
That evening, he returned.
“I heard the buzzer going in the shop and I said to Dermot ‘I’ll get this’. And then I saw something come at me so I pushed my hands up to stop whatever it was coming at me, which was a knife,” said Bridget.
He was just screaming. Unmerciful screaming like a wild animal.
The man stabbed Bridget and then stabbed Dermot to death. One of the last things Dermot said to his wife was:
“Call an ambulance, I’ve been stabbed.”
“I remember trying to bargain with God to spare him,” said Bridget.
“And the more they worked on him, there was just volumes of blood coming out of him and eventually I just said ‘I know he’s dead, you can stop working on him’.”
Dermot was the third Irish national to be murdered in Melbourne within one year. His killer was Gavin Perry, who was sentenced to 27 years in prison for his crime. Perry was out on parole and had around 200 offences to his name, including armed robbery.
Vicious attack
A year before Dermot O’Toole’s death, a 30-year old Cabinteely man David Greene – Davey to his friends – was attacked in Melbourne.
“The whole thing, it is like a dream,” said his father Aidan.
Greene was described as a character. ”He’d just charm anybody,” his mum said.
Work had dried up at home in Ireland so, like many Irish people, Greene went to Australia, where he ended up working in a hostel.
He told his family that a man – named Luke Wentholt - who was a “bit weird” had moved into his shared house.
One night there was a party at the house. Towards the end of the night, Wentholt accused Greene of making a move on his girlfriend, then attacked him viciously.
He also attacked another Irish man who came to his defence. The two men were admitted to hospital in serious condition. David’s life support machine was turned off after more than a week, and he died in hospital.
The other Irish man, David Byas, survived his injuries. “No one knows unless they go through it themselves what the pain is like losing a child that way,” said Greene’s mother.
Wentholt, who had a number of previous convictions, was charged with Greene’s murder and sentenced to at least 15 years in prison.
Jill Meagher murder
That same year, Jill Meagher went missing in Brunswick, Melbourne during a night out. She was taken, raped and then murdered by Adrian Bayley, a rapist out on parole.
Public anger grew over a parole system that allowed Bayley out when he was a danger to the public. Gavin Perry was also allowed out on parole by the Parole Board of Victoria just months after Meagher’s death.
O’Toole family’s now campaign for tougher sentencing and tighter restrictions on parole in Victoria after Dermot’s tragic death.
Murder in Melbourne follows as these Irish families deal with their devastating loss and follows their journey to get justice for their loved ones.
Murder in Melbourne is broadcast on Monday 7 March on RTÉ One
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
First went to London in the early 80′s working in bars , met so many Irish who hadn’t been home in years , men like these ….God rest them.
With the funds raised , it would be nice to bring them home to Cork and bury them in their hometown , together .
“They are believed to have been estranged for a number of years”. Being buried together might not be what they want!
I worked in London for 20years and there are a lot of old Irish over there who worked very hard in a time when Irish weren’t welcomed and have lost touch with home and have no family around , very sad .
RIP lads
An example of how disposable that generation of immigrants were for ireland. It really does seem we dumped people out like trash on the edge of english society.
Well austerity has managed to do the same to several generations in the last five years. This country likes to hurt it’s own
they have paid enough taxes and PRSI to cover burial cost
How did you work that out ? according to the article they went to London when they where about 18
Like many Irish people who have gone before me, I made North London my temporary home and saw some very sad cases of older generations falling through the gaps. Always lend support to London Irish Centre and other welfare organisations that provide support and comfort to people living in isolation. The once bustling Irish communities such as Kilburn, Cricklewood, Willesden etc are experiencing dwindling Irish populations that contribute to isolation of older people who might not be able to afford to move.
“Two Irish twins”? Two twins suggests four people, am I being pedantic? Don’t mean to be.
Pedantic and incorrect.
Pedantic?? More like D!ckhead
Joe, you’re not being pedantic. Pedantry is excessive or slavish attention to rules. You’re simply ignorant of the basic meaning of simple words.
“Two twins” simply means two people who are twins. It might be redundant, as the fact that they are twins tells us that there are two of them. But “twin” doesn’t mean “set of twins”, nor does “two” mean “four”.
the problem to me reading all these stories nowadays is that the effort should be put in before they die, I never heard too many complain about the size of their own funeral
When is the funeral. Ill go of I can get off work.
If I understand this correctly, the brothers emigrated in the mid-1950′s and since then their country of origin didn’t care about them – and they didn’t care about their country. In the intervening years they became estranged even from each other. This is sad, but why all the hullabaloo now, when they are dead?
Good point Rashers but a lot of time older Irish people feel that they cannot go back to Ireland for psychological reasons. They feel that Ireland has moved on, England being the country they lived most of their lives in and Irish people were not always accepted in this society either. Another thing is that Irish people sometimes feel that they didn’t make a success of their life over in England and couldn’t face going back home without a huge incinerate and having made a success of themselves. Not saying that this is the case here but it happens more often than not.
Unidentical I assume
Because the authorities do not want to pay for the funerals and that is a main reason for this?
have your say