Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE BROADCASTING AUTHORITY has dismissed a complaint made against Newstalk presenter George Hook, after a woman claimed he was fuelling hate speech against Muslims.
Fiona Martyn complained that, during his show The Right Hook, the presenter had dismissed the idea that exam timings should be altered to avoid scheduling during Ramadan.
She said Hook “appeared to believe that nobody thought there should be allowances during the Christian Lenten period and so a student fasting during daylight hours shouldn’t be accommodated in 2016 in the manner proposed”.
The woman also stated that the presenter likened Muslim students to the gangs in Germany responsible for sexual assaults against women.
The complainant states these remarks, which she describes as “ugly and vilifying rants” add fuel to anti-Islamic and racist hate speech in communities.
In response, Newstalk said Hook’s intention was to probe the reasons why exam times should change, and that he was not expressing an opinion on whether or not they should be.
The broadcaster also said he in no way likened students of Islamic faith to those who perpetrated sexual attacks on women in Germany.
Rather, he proceeded with his point about political correctness to suggest that a desire to be politically correct may have been the reason that the ethnicity of those responsible for the New Year’s Eve attacks in Germany was not disclosed until a week after they occurred.
The broadcaster states that in the course of making this point, the presenter stated as fact that the German police had now identified these attackers as of Arabic descent.
Newstalk rejected the suggestion that this amounted to an “ugly and vilifying rant” as suggested by Martin.
The committee determined that the content of the discussion did not stigmatise, support or condone discrimination or incite hatred. It also found that the two stories were “approached in the usual style of the programme presenter, which can be robust and challenging, but which is intended to provoke a response from listeners”.
The complaint was rejected.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Trump’s foreign diplomacy has led to largest de-escalation of hostilities between North and South Korea in 60 years since the war, but look at the how the headline in wrote, always with the negative spin. This site is pure biased propaganda
@Save The 8th: foreign diplomacy! Tit for tat import taxs against china and steel etc…..
@Save The 8th: Nothing has happened yet. The summit could lead to an escalation. Let’s wait and see.
@David Repealion: yea, two cranky kids meeting up could get messy….”ive a bigger red button, beautiful red button”……
@Save The 8th: Why were the US meddling in korea 60 ago?
@Save The 8th: what is negative about the headline?
Trump is a lying fat orange skinned pig headed self aggrandising woman hating buffoon….Now THHAT is negative
@Dave Harris: Stop body shaming, bigot.
The Journal secretly has still not let comments to open on the Paddy Jackson trial
@Donnacha Bhoicaire: and that affects your life why?
Left wing journalism and the Irish sheep who follow. The headline is as misleading as Rte and Ireland Am. And the people on here criticizing the US, let’s see Ireland mobilize their military and actually do something for once.. not happening but if anything ever happened to the Emerald Isle then the US would be the first country you’d look to. Bunch of left wing sheep, you only wish your leaders had a set of balls but unfortunately theirs were taken by the EU.
@Jerry Wise: No marmalade for your toast?
@Jerry Wise: how is the headline
“Misleading”?
@Jerry Wise: Waffle
The US broke every treaty they made with the indigenous population. look what happened to libya. beware NK.
Hardly that secret, sure it’s in the journal…
A secret meeting, how romantic.
have your say