Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
https://youtu.be/2Uc3MX1yRPk
RAY D’ARCY HAS responded to criticism of his radio show’s handling of the abortion debate over the last year.
The Broadcasting Authority of Ireland upheld complaints against the RTÉ Radio 1 programme’s coverage of the issue on two occasions over the past 12 months (last December and in May). Other complaints against the show were either rejected or upheld in part.
The presenter returned to the national broadcaster from Today FM at the start of last year, and has come in for criticism several times since then for his coverage of contentious issues. The BAI also rejected two complaints that D’Arcy covered last year’s same-sex marriage referendum in an unfair way.
He has come in for particular criticism from the Pro Life Campaign for coverage of the abortion issue, and in a ruling last December the BAI found “listeners to the programme would have reasonably concluded that the presenter endorsed the views of his interviewee” during an interview with Amnesty’s Colm O’Gorman, who supports repealing the Eighth Amendment.
Asked about those BAI rulings in an interview with TheJournal.ie, D’Arcy said:
I think if you read back through the judgments over the last year you will find that, for example, the BAI say that we are allowed to have people on telling personal stories – you know? So that’s a slight change.
He also brought up, in his answer, a segment from the show that aired earlier this month featuring senator and pro-life campaigner Rónán Mullen.
Mullen took the opportunity during the course of the discussion to attack D’Arcy’s previous coverage of abortion – prompting fierce debate, once again, on social media.
Here’s what D’Arcy had to say about that item:
“The other thing about the repeal of the Eighth Amendment is – we had Rónán Mullen on, Senator Rónán Mullen on, recently and I was in the middle of the interview with him…
“So, me – [a] middle-aged man – talking to Rónán Mullen, who is a middle-aged man… Then we had a woman on the phone from England talking about post-abortion counselling – a service that her organisation were offering Irish women
And it struck me – I got this out-of-body thing – that this is a microcosm of the problem, you know that there’s two middle-aged men and a woman from England talking about issues that concern Irish women’s bodies.
Asked if he might have responded differently to Mullen’s comments, had the segment aired on commercial radio, he said:
It might have been a different interview if it was on Today FM, it may have been.
There’s a higher degree of scrutiny for hosts on the national broadcaster, compared to the commercial sector, D’Arcy explained.
Asked about how he handled that change, moving from Today FM to RTÉ just as the marriage debate was gathering pace, he said that “when you move to a state broadcaster, it’s different – and it just took me a while to adjust”.
Management at RTÉ need to take a look at policies on balance and fairness, he said.
“Sometimes in debates we don’t serve our public best by being strictly black and white – we have somebody on from the Yes side – three minutes – somebody from the No side – three minutes.
Because a lot of things are nuanced, there’s a lot of grey, so it’s not just simply Yes and No, it’s not black and white – so I think we just need to have a chat about that, we need to have a discussion about that. That hasn’t happened yet.
The Ray D’Arcy Show returns to TV on RTÉ One this Saturday at 9.40pm. We’ll have more from our interview later in the week.
–Camera work and editing by Nicky Ryan
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Democracy is more important than ever as we see where the USA is headed. Wherever we were, they could be relied on to at least keep a free and open society as an ideal, in principle. That’s finished. The autocrats are on the march. The old world order is ending and the forces of anti-democracy, tyranny and hate are on the march. We are entering very very dark times.
@SerotoninWars: We’re never heading into good times, it’s literally never been said. Probs doesn’t generate enough ‘revenue’ across society.
@SerotoninWars: those which got into power both in the USA and in most areas in eu brought most of these issues now faced on us themselves. They’re stupidity and lack of forward long term planning and thinking has helped these so called far right actually gain momentum by allowing the likes of housing crisis to balloon altogether singlehandedly they have frustrated people to turn theyre thinking. In order to prevent far right gaining anymore ground,if thats what they’re actually trying to prevent, they need to concentrate solely on eu member states and how to serve those effectively not everyone outside of it. Halt immigration and only allow necessary people in for now such as health services etc. Get things in order get supply to one day meet demand then see about those outside eu.
@Thesaltyurchin: There are levels to it. The USA is highly imperfect and often hypocritical but it has, for a long time, been a bulwark for international democracy and rule of law. If there’s no pressure from the USA, this will do nothing but encourage the despots. If, as looks probable, Trump gets in, he will interpret the ruling today as a carte blanche to do whatever he likes. He’s too stupid and selfish to understand nuance. And with that Supreme Court behind him he’ll go much further with his stooges in ripping up the rule book. This is far more serious than the usual takes of political woe: it’s a disaster. Unless you wish to see the hardest right of governments, lots of unchecked power and dynasties emerging in former democracies.
@Paddy C: I agree that no matter what your politics, there’s going to have to be some new consensus with some painful decisions to avoid a slide into far right governments everywhere. There’s a huge difference between the protest vote scenario where people want a couple of specific things changed and a wholesale sweep to the far right who have a whole lot of other policies in mind too for when they get into power. So yes, I agree a new dynamic is required. Banging our heads off a brick wall will solve nothing.
@SerotoninWars: this is what people need to understand we have to find a happy medium somewhere otherwise it’ll go to far and the wrong people altogether will get in then we’re into a whole new set of problems we need to now take maybe what some would consider difficult decisions to avoid it.
@Paddy C: I agree. For people like me who lean left we have to remember that there’s a world of difference between centrist conservative governments you might not be fully happy with and actual far right parties. Parties that attract full blown fascists. There are many decent and kind conservatives. There’s no one like that in the far right. Worrying times as we need to generate pushback against the Putin’s of this world, not more allies for him.
Fair play to Cllr John Lyons Dublin City Council for calling out the extortionate prices for the ” affordable” homes in
the Coolock development. Free land given to the developer who screws the council with their money grabbing tactics.All done with the support of ffg and labour.
A certain individual a number of years ago remarked that irelands councillors and politicians ‘ make the mafia look like choirboys”.Democracy me a..e
@D. Peadar: when the general election comes anybody who isn’t usually pushed needs to get out and vote for the sake of it. Even if you don’t want to bother getting involved voting normally just make the effort this time if you want you’re children and generations to come having somewhat of a normal future prospect. In others words hope of a decent job which will cover having a roof over they’re heads and at some point if they wish to, a family and be able to survive and have that chance. Otherwise this country is doomed with a falling birth rate because of what’s just mentioned pension and health systems will without a doubt not be sustainable despite what horseshit comes out of the likes of roderic o gorman and the rest of those fairy’s in there.
Sums it up very well. This is being reflected in the decisions being made executive level and which elected councillors have no real say.
Excellent article
Our local councillors are really just administrators
Dublin ( city centre) is in serious decline because nobody is accountable or responsible
If we want to get people believing in democracy we need to make it much more powerful at a local level as that’s what affects people in their daily levels. We also need a much more interactive system than merely casting a vote every 4 or 5 years
Good article Pat! (Think Copenhagen built like 3 light rail systems during Coivd, certainly that needs a fact check tho lol!).
Well said Pat
The people have spoken and said they are very content with FFG, who regained control at local govt with the support of INDependents, Greens and Labour. #HappyPeople #HappyGovt #NoIssues
@9QRixo8H: Remember the 2019 local election went for FF/FG ? Then remember how the 2020 general election for FF/FG. It’ll tell you the local election means absolutely nothing. The next general election is all that matters.
@Ger Whelan:
A fair point Ger but in 2020 SF caught the mood of discontent and profited big time, and continued upward in the years since until recently, immigration and the recent referendums (especially the promise to run it again!) caught them badly.
It’s easier when you have momentum, extremely hard to turn it around when it’s going the other way
The whole western world is shifting right (except the UK!) Ireland is no different.
A backlash against the cost of green policies is another core factor in that rightward shift.
@Ger Whelan: There are only 3 parties running enough candidates to lead a govt, and the FFG duo maintained their support, so what do you think will happen?
@P. J.: It’s D.peader who needs this explanation not me
@9QRixo8H: They were well supported in the local elections in 2019 weren’t they? In fact overall the win more seats in 2019 than this year’s local elections. As for what happened? I don’t know. But I’m not here bragging how great things looked for any party am I?. Local elections mean absolutely nothing
@9QRixo8H: when the general election comes anybody who isn’t usually pushed needs to get out and vote for the sake of it. Even if you don’t want to bother getting involved voting normally just make the effort this time if you want you’re children and generations to come having somewhat of a normal future project. In others words hope of a decent job which will cover having a roof over they’re heads and at some point if they wish to, a family and be able to survive and have that chance. Otherwise ghis country is doomed with a falling birth rate because of what’s just mentioned pension and health systems will without a doubt not be sustainable despite what horseshit comes out of the likes of roderic o gorman and the rest of those fairy’s in there.
@Paddy C: vote for who? Majority want FFG. Birth rates are falling? If only we had immigration so men wouldn’t want to force women to give birth.
@9QRixo8H: they don’t need to force them just realise that when they’re born they might end up in a tent,b&b or hostel growing up for most of they’re lives. That’s no future at all and that is reality despite the horse crap that shower of utterly useless baffons in the dail are putting out.
@Paddy C: how can a young couple plan on having they’re own family and a home when neither can even afford to rent a room in a flat. They can’t so they’ve given up on that dream and are travelling abroad or trying to have that dream abroad,shame they can’t have it here when they,they’re families and friends all contributed into the tax system most of they’re lives.
@9QRixo8H: So you would prefer to have more Muslims here, who force women to do whatever they say? You simpleminded fkng dope.
SF were supposed to be the next big thing. Nobody knew for sure if they were far-left or far-right.
When the chips are down, people prefer the devil they know.
have your say