Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE BROADCASTING AUTHORITY has upheld a complaint made about the FM104 Phoneshow with Chris Barry, after a caller made a number of offensive comments about children with special needs.
The complaint was made by a Theresa Finn in July this year and referred to a discussion about the exclusion of special needs children from summer camps.
It was sparked by a Facebook status by a parent on the topic and there were a number of calls from other parents in a similar position or people who sympathised.
However, one caller questioned what would happen if a child at a camp “spazzes out”.
Other comments included:
They don’t have a head of their own…they don’t have a mind of their own.
They are kinda…stupid.
At the end of the day, you can’t put a mongo into a camp.
You can’t have a cabbage in a camp.
A cabbage won’t punch the head off of me, no mongo will punch the head off of me.
The woman who made the complaint said she was “appalled and disgusted” at what she considered to be “vile abuse” that was allowed to be broadcast.
She said she had personal experience dealing with children with autism and she did not expect to hear “abusive, hateful comments towards the most vulnerable children in our society”.
‘Idiotic’
In its response FM104 said, as with any topic, some listeners to the programme will be “ignorant” in respect of it. The broadcaster also stated the caller was challenged by both the presenter and other callers, and told his views were “idiotic”, “insulting” and “ignorant”.
FM104 said the man was eventually cut off.
The broadcaster states that the show contains views and opinions that not everyone agrees with, but these views are always challenged on-air, as was the case on this night.
FM104 also denied ”hyping anyone up” before going on-air to be disrespectful towards children with special needs and claimed it does not have the time or resources to pre-interview every caller.
In its decision, the BAI noted the programme is broadcast after the watershed, but said there are certain limits in respect of acceptable content.
This includes a requirement on broadcasters to ensure that content is in line with general community standards, including standards related to public attitudes to language. Furthermore, content must represent persons and groups in society appropriately and in a justified manner and should not prejudice human dignity.
Though it acknowledged that the callers comments had been challenged, the authority said it was evident from early in his contribution that this man’s views were “highly offensive”.
The committee also noted that he was permitted to make the above types of remarks for a considerable period of time before his comments were strongly challenged by the presenter. There was also no evidence from the broadcaster that the presenter or the programme makers ended the call.
In view of these factors, the authority determined the broadcaster would be issued with a compliance notice and will be monitored by the BAI.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Split kilkenny in 2
The cats are alive and well.Meow!!
@James Leahy: still NO all Ireland for kilkenny
@Alan Moloney: how would you know oh wise one?
Dublin were very poor today. Once Kk got their first goal it was curtains for Dublin. Dublin were lucky Kilkenny didn’t play to their full potential as they would have been absolutely destroyed. The result/score was bad enough but Dublin never got going apart from a few players like Eoghan O’Donnell and there was no fight or pride in them. It was absolutely shocking
@DJ D: They were absolutely destroyed
@another one? what’s going on is the semi state sec: I was referring to Kilkenny not playing to their true potential because if they had it would have been 30 or 40 points in the difference. You might understand now!!!
@DJ D: irrelevant comment….. “If Kilkenny played to their true potential”…… Dublin didn’t turn up! That comment might mean something if Dublin played their best. What if Dublin played to their true potential, it would have been less of a score difference.
@DJ D: Hard luck Mrs O’Donnell .
@Gerry Campbell: Gobshyte
Leinster hurling is just KK and Galway. This year Galway not really at the races and it shows because noone else can step up to challenge. Tomorrow is the real deal though
@FoxyBoiiYT: “Galway not at the races”?!?!? They played 3/4 of the game against Dublin with 14 men.
Dublin gave KK way too much space. There is no marking in the first half at times. Tougher test ahead.
Leinster championships in football and hurling are a complete joke
@Tim & Emer Brennan: You clearly don’t watch leinster hurling
@S K: sorry kilkenny don’t break sweat
Dubs been beaten by double scores for a change
A day Dublin will hopefully educate ourselves from , But what goes on tomorrow in simple will have another question. To ask ourselves
Why are Dublin so crap at Hurling?
have your say