We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
THE ADVERTISING STANDARDS Authority for Ireland has upheld complaints made against Carphone Warehouse relating to their “Pro-Choice” adverts that briefly featured on internet, social media and outdoors.
Complainants had said that the adverts were offensive and trivialised sensitive topics.
Carphone Warehouse have agreed not to use the phrase as a slogan in future marketing material.
Pro-choice
One of the adverts featured a picture of a denim jacket with a badge pinned just beneath the collar. The badge reads: “We’re Pro-Choice”.
The bottom of the advertisement then reads: “The only place you get to choose your network, phone and plan. Carphone Warehouse.”
Another advert featured a baby wearing a vest, and posed the question: “What makes a family? Mum and Mum. Mum and Dad. Dad and Dad.” Again, it also featured the same byline about choosing the phone, network and plan, as well as the Pro-Choice slogan.
Over 40 complaints were received regarding these two adverts.
The ASAI said that the “common theme” among these complaints was the wording in the ad mirroring the wording used by campaigners looking to repeal the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution.
They said: “The majority of complainants strongly considered that the use of the wording ‘Pro-Choice’ in the current climate was highly offensive and trivialised a very sensitive topic, particularly as it was linked to the sale of mobile phones/plans.”
In response, Carphone Warehouse said they had “neither nor promoted abortion”. Their “position” was they had simply believed in the value and right of choice.
The complaints against these adverts were upheld and the ASAI told Carphone Warehouse not to use the slogan again.
Offensive
Another Carphone Warehouse advert that received a complaint featured as a banner advertisement on the company website.
The ASAI detailed: “It featured the head and shoulders of a person with a neutral expression. The person had a short hairstyle and wore a collarless tee-shirt with straps going over the shoulders.”
The text then asks “What do you see? Guy. Girl. Me.”
The complainant said “the implication on viewing the advertisement was that transgender people ‘choose’ their gender and that such ‘choice’ was frivolous”.
In response, Carphone Warehouse said they had “hoped that the universal answer might have been the person rather than their gender”.
In conclusion, the ASAI said: “The Committee noted that the advertisers would not use the wording ‘Pro Choice’ in future marketing material and on that basis no further action was required in relation to this issue.
The Committee told the advertisers, however, that advertisement No. 3 should not be used in its current format again.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Looking for attention. And they got it. Job done. That’s what advertising is for.
Some clever little advertising agent is in for a big Christmas bonus. P
^^^^ the P was a mistake : (
^^^^^^ I thought the P was your unique selling point……..
Oh I’d be surprised if they didn’t fire their agency
Where can I complain about people that make complaints about ads or programming? If you’re offended by something then that’s your problem. Build a bridge and get over it.
@David: Sounds like you are making a complaint!
David. . I like your thinking .. don’t see how these people can’t just change channels if they like the add !
So abortion lobbyists own the word “choice” now? And are denying it to others? How liberal
Price genocide on your new Samsung. A holocaust on higher costs.
Campaign Aborted
The satire is strong in Hyou.
Pinochet couldn’t make phones disappear this fast! Hurry hurry hurry!
Or Gerry Adams…
100% a guy
Thought all these anti choice people were saying people who don’t like how the country is should leave it back before the marriage equality referendum. Why are some of them still here?
Jeffrey.
Can you write that again please with better diction. I can’t make any sense of what you’ve just said.
The fact these people were offended offends me.
Just shows how stupid I am.. I thought they were only pointing out they were not tied to any single operator ….Thanks for enlightened me. Now I’m horrified. .Stop that sort of thing . immediately.
have your say