We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
THE SMALL WESTERN town of Ballaghaderreen has been shunted front and centre in the last week, into a limelight it isn’t particularly comfortable with.
The Department of Justice’s (DOJ) announcement that an Emergency Reception and Orientation Centre (EROC) for refugees is to be established in the town garnered national headlines and unleashed something of a media storm in the area. There will be at least 80 people as part of the first tranche of arrivals, most of them children, most of them Syrian, with that number probably rising to 240 (though not all remaining at the same time).
The orientation process is to last for six months in Roscommon before the new arrivals are integrated elsewhere around the country.
Less than 24 hours notice was given to the town’s representatives prior to the announcement. Officially, the DOJ explained that the situation is an emergency, and word was given as soon as was reasonably practicable.
As things stand, relatively few details have emerged as to how the process is actually going to work. The first refugees are now expected towards the end of February or the start of March. Apart from this, there are few concrete details.
Cianan Brennan / TwitterIn #ballaghaderreen to report on incoming refugee situation. Abbeyfield Hotel is placed right on town outskirts. It's closed off however pic.twitter.com/m9NK8FIHhT
— Cianan Brennan (@ciananbrennan) January 12, 2017
The reaction of the community has been heartening to independent observers. However, there remains a certain discontent with how the news was disseminated. There are also worries that the town’s infrastructure is simply not capable of supplying the services that the new arrivals will certainly need.
Unemployment
Ballaghaderreen, Co Roscommon, has a population of just shy of 2,000. The town is really two streets (one long, one slightly shorter) intersecting with each other in a manner that will be familiar to any who have travelled through the west of Ireland.
The town, objectively, is not a well-off one. Its unemployment rate of 32.4% in 2011 (as of that year’s Census, the most recently available data) was nearly twice the then national average.
Still, jobs are certainly hard to come by in the town. Although there are at least eight pubs and numerous clothes stores, boarded-up or derelict businesses are ten-a-penny.
There are also almost 300 vacant houses sitting idle. The town has the Celtic Tiger to thank for that.
The major employers include Aurivo (an agri-food plant with about 70 employees), an ECMI cigar factory, a bacon factory and a library and offices at the Dillon House complex in the town.
Aside from that, many residents commute to nearby towns (Boyle, Castlebar, Carrick-on-Shannon) for work. Knock Airport is just 10 minutes away, but employs “a handful of people from the town at most”, according to Fr Joe Gavigan, the parish priest.
When asked about unemployment, Gavigan visibly flinches.
“There is very high unemployment here. It’s one of the major bones of contention in the community,” he says.
No guarantees
The arrival of refugees to the town should, in theory, help that figure. The new centre, to be developed in the confines of the disused four-star Abbeyfield Hotel, will require staffing – maintenance, cleaning etc.
While no guarantees have been made that employment will be sourced locally, Junior Minister for Justice David Stanton has assured stakeholders that every effort would be made to do so.
But employment, or resentment of newcomers, doesn’t really appear to be a problem.
Ballaghaderreen is already about as diverse a western Irish town as you could think of. There are very substantial populations of eastern European citizens and Pakistanis (many of whom worked in the Halal Meats factory which closed 10 years ago and stayed on thereafter) in the town.
What’s more, the town has already been the site of a (now defunct) Direct Provision centre. Many of that centre’s former residents (it closed nine years ago) still live locally.
A discussion meeting held in Spells pub in the town last Monday saw at least 100 people in attendance. No politicians were allowed to speak (in their official capacity at any rate). The meeting was seen as an unqualified success, with a huge amount of people leaving their contact details at the end of the night together with information on ways they think they can assist with the volunteer effort.
The organisers of the Welcome movement are unfailingly positive about what is to come. They see it as an opportunity, not an imposition.
If there is an undercurrent of resentment, it lies in citizens feeling the town only exists for the government to use at its convenience when it comes to awkward situations.
A welcome for the refugees is a given. Love for the Department of Justice is in scant supply however.
Abbeyfield Hotel
In declaring that Ballaghaderreen would be the site of a new centre, the Department of Justice gave local representatives mere hours’ notice before the announcement hit the front pages nationally.
The Abbeyfield Hotel closed its doors in 2010, a victim of the recession, after just a handful of years in operation.
Having lain derelict since (the hotel is one of the largest structures in the area, located just on the outskirts on the Dublin-side of town), it was bought by investors from Cork in 2015 which led to a period of frenzied refurbishment.
It has been argued elsewhere that the Department was entirely correct to hold off on giving the town notice of the plans; the idea being that if a long run-in was given to the establishment of the centre, it would merely give locals time to mobilise in opposition to it. Not everyone agrees with that theory however.
“It’s the lack of confidence in us that grates,” says Mary Gallagher (75), who runs a clothing store in the town along with her husband.
She says there will be a “cautious welcome” for the new residents.
“Well, what do we say to refugees looking for shelter? We can’t run to Mass and then come back and say ‘no, you’re not wanted’. That would make us great hypocrites, wouldn’t it? These are people who have come through horrific circumstances. We will do our best to make them feel at home.”
But there are also questions as to why empty houses standing idle aren’t being used. “I don’t think the hotel is the right place for them though. This town is full of empty houses, why not there?” continues Gallagher.
It’s the fact that it all boils down to money, that’s what sickens me. Someone in the background is making a bit of a buck. Well I don’t want to make a buck on the back of immigrants.
Excitement
For those willing to be quoted, the reaction to the news in Ballaghaderreen is remarkable for its positivity. More than one person expressed their unabashed excitement at the prospect of new arrivals.
Secretary of Ballaghaderreen GAA Club (which actually competes across the border in the Mayo county championship) Andrew Durkin (whose family run the only guest house in the town since the demise of the Abbeyfield as a going concern) tells us he can see nothing but positives.
The club has already agreed at a general meeting to send envoys to the new centre to “take a few, well not coaching sessions, but create a few fun occasions with the kids”.
Has he seen any resentment? “No, none whatsoever, we’re a pretty open people. To be honest, if the information is out there for people, and they’re not being kept in the dark, then they tend to be a lot more accepting.”
Sajjad (Saj for short) Hussain, meanwhile, runs one of the town’s barber shops.
A Pakistani national, he’s been living in Ireland for 15 years, and in Ballaghaderreen for 10, where he’s married with two children. He is manager of the town’s cricket team, and someone who smiles and laughs easily. He was also one of many contributors at last Monday’s meeting, a speech that apparently had people ‘in tears’ when he suggested that the only thing the Syrian newcomers will need when they arrive ‘is love’.
“They should tell us clearly what the facilities are going to be, the government. But the refugees? No, I don’t think anyone has any problem with them at all,” he tells us.
Some people don’t like to put their name out maybe, but I think people might just be worried because of a lack of information. I mean, all these people will be garda-checked before they get here. There is nothing to worry about.
Saj describes the Abbeyfield as “a beautiful, fabulous hotel”.
“Maybe it is too good for Ballaghaderreen?” he smiles. He thinks the town is ready for its new challenge.
If the government give more information, and helps out with employing people, then I think the people here are good-hearted, they are very good and welcoming. It will be fine.
Official lines
The official integration will be handled by the local Community Development Programme (CDP). The Welcome to Roscommon movement meanwhile has been set up so that locals can volunteer their time and expertise.
Debbie Beirne, one of the organisers of last Monday’s meeting and one of the chief personalities behind the Welcome movement, says she is “100% certain” the community’s reaction to the new arrivals will be a welcoming one.
“It’s only when these people get here that everything will fall into place. Could this help the community? Oh it absolutely could. Since my earliest memory we’ve had a multinational community here, this is nothing new to us,” she says.
She can understand the DOJ’s policy of little-or-no information as regards the centre:
“I’d actually like to think their was wisdom behind their decision. They may have seen it as avoiding whipping up a storm. But that decision may not have been made out of wisdom.”
We put it to her that not all the reaction we have seen from the town’s citizens has been as universally positive as her own. What does she think?
“They’re entitled to their opinion. I don’t see them as reflective of the community. Have these people travelled the world? Have they seen other nationalities and religions? Have they experienced how other people live?
To be honest, if there are such sentiments I haven’t heard them, I’ve heard the exact opposite. But then I would be the wrong person to be saying those things to.
Negativity
The negative reactions we mention have one thing in common – speaking to townspeople, those in question initially do not want to speak, certainly don’t want to be quoted and are distrustful of the media in general (of whom they have had their fill in the last seven days). Gradually, however, they come out of their shell.
“How could I say anything bad about them, these are people, they’ve come through dreadful things,” says one woman. “But we’re just a small town, what do we have to offer them? I can’t imagine they are overly excited to be coming to Ballaghaderreen either. Or is it someone just making money?”
“I have no problem with them coming here, we’ll do our best for them,” says another. “My concern would be that we don’t have anything like the services here in place to deal with this.”
One other point of view expressed was that “Ballaghaderreen has done enough”, is “losing its Irishness”, and that “most people in the town are afraid to say what they think”. Whether this be truthful or no, it’s an opinion that was only expressed to us in one place.
Only one truly negative situation has presented itself in the town since the announcement was made eight days ago. In the immediate aftermath, a graphic, anti-Islamic flyer was distributed through letterboxes. The incident appears to be an isolated one however, and gardaí are taking it seriously.
Positivity
“Look, I’m a realist,” says Michael Frain, a community leader (and fire officer) who runs a local print shop, of possible negative reactions within the town.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and if Ballaghaderreen is representative of the country as a whole, you would be worried if there weren’t conflicting opinions.
“People are looking at the TV and they’re seeing Aleppo and bombing and they think that’s going to be it. Add that to the vacuum that happened when this thing was announced, you can understand a view that there would be issues around all this.”
But I can hopefully say in six months time, the sky won’t have fallen in. I can’t see anything to be worried about with this situation to be honest.
Frain, someone who oozes positivity, allows that the loss of the Abbeyfield is a disappointment. He also acknowledges that the selection of Ballaghaderreen by the DOJ, and the “mechanism by which that decision was relayed”, has to be questioned. However:
“I’m in community development all my life, we try to bring employment to the town, we tried to get that hotel going. Of course we’re disappointed.
But who’s to say that hotel won’t open again? This isn’t forever.
The suggestion of negative reactions is one that clearly irks him, something he feels the media has had more than a little hand in cultivating.
“What really annoys me is people come to town and put microphones under people’s noses, and maybe those people aren’t working themselves, they have strong opinions, and they’re being taken as Gospel. But then you have people who have nothing in this town and they’re welcoming these people with open arms. Others have worked with organisations around the world and have retired and have come back to help and support the town.”
Has Ballaghaderreen, in an opinion expressed elsewhere, ‘done enough’?
Done enough? What does that really mean? The opportunity here is to be a shining example of what a town in the west of Ireland can do, and in years to come people will say ‘that’s a place that has done something for humanity’, I want to base my business there.
“When we had the Direct Provision centre here, we used to have a clean-up-the-streets effort for Tidy Towns every Saturday, and there may not have been townspeople involved, but they came out when they saw the residents of the centre out helping. They said they were ashamed to have people from another country cleaning up their rubbish. Every Saturday. We’ve learned a lot in the last number of years.”
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
The sentences given out for dangerous and careless driving that results in death are unbelievably lenient. Two such drivers recently killed two cyclists were not given custodial sentences.
@Kal Ipers: We just legalised killing.
@Kal Ipers: It’s not black or white – what exactly happened with those two cyclists?
You could be done for careless driving even if a person stepped out in front of you because as a driver you are responsible but in fairness sometimes you just don’t get the chance to stop in time.
When a person is speeding, drunk etc. then a sentence should be applied.
@B9xiRspG: In both cases the drivers were deemed 100% at fault. One of them turned around to take labels off her child’s toy while driving. The other was simply not paying attention and drove into a cyclist. They were black and white cases unless you think there is mitigation in turning around to the back seat and not looking at the road while driving.
@Padraic Reid: Be quite, insane comment
@Padraic Reid: yep
Why can’t we deport these guys back to their country of origin when they actively break our laws. They add only to our crime stats and contribute nothing but misery! Why should the tax payer pay for the upkeep of these undesirables when they get convicted?
@Paddy: He’s Lithuanian, an EU country.
It’s a beautiful country. Vilnius is absolutely stunning.
@Paddy: Because if the worst that can happen is deportation then the foreigners don’t really get punished and will commit more crimes
@Dave Doyle: Dave, we could deport after they serve their sentence or send them home to serve the sentence there.
End of the day we should ban people that commit crime from our country. I don’t care if they are EU or not.
@B9xiRspG: If you read the original comment from Paddy properly, you will see he advocates deporting criminals before they serve a sentence (read the bit where he mentions upkeep etc). My comment was a reply to this so I am not advocating that we don’t deport them at the end of their sentence or that they don’t serve a sentence back home. Infact I think all foreign prisoners should automatically be deported after completing their punishment. If you read the EU legislation you will find that it does not in anyway prohibit deportation of criminals and that EU and Non-Eu criminals are treated the same in terms of deportation
@Dave Doyle: this guy is a violent criminal with convictions all over the country. If he had been kicked out of the country after the first or second conviction another young man would be alive today, in 2015 the cost to house a criminal was 1800 euros a week. So ya this guy has now cost one man his life and now he’s gonna cost the state millions!
The Gardai and courts system need to be held to account for this case. Personnel within these organisations need to answer and be held accountable for their failures.
@Reg: we don’t do accountability in this country
@Reg: Why the Gardai? They have arrested him numerous times and each time the courts have left him out on bail. The Gardai can’t force the judge to imprison the person. The judges need to be held responsible.
What we really need is, unfortunately, more prisons because right now “minor” crimes are getting off free because there’s no room for them.
@B9xiRspG: Did you see the Prime Time piece last night Jim?
@Dermot Lane: When the Gov start to throw enquries around the place like confette, you can bet that something big is about to hit the fan.
@Dermot Lane: Please leave the referendum banks water charges out of this.
@B9xiRspG: it’s cool to criticise the guards weather it’s their fault or not
@Ohhh_reeally: well they need to be blamed in this case
@Reg: are you satisfied that Prime Time have done a more extensive investigation into the incident than GSOC?
@Joe Bloggs: The GSOC report was the basis for the Prime Time report. Are you happy that an hour or so before Shane O’Farrell was killed that the car was stopped containing Zigimantas Gradzuiska, that he wasn’t insured, the car did not have a valid NCT certificate and he was allowed to continue his journey?
@Reg: could be wrong Reg but don’t the Gardai have to give a person 10 days to present their insurance and can only take the car if they know for sure the person is uninsured?
@Paul: There’s a national insurance database that the Gardai have access to….did they check? Maybe we’ll find out in another 5 or 6 years.
@Reg: no such thing
@Reg: what’s this national insurance database????? One doesn’t exist
@Michael Powell: Been around for a few years as far as I know – http://www.nfd.ie
@Reg: motor tax and nct can be looked up no problem. Insurance DB isn’t relabile as it’s not constantly updated and maintained with valid information because insurance companies and brokers aren’t full on board. Another half ass job
Do you remember we had a referendum to get rid of the right to bail. It passed but we still let dangerous people out on the streets. Didn’t act too quickly on that referendum
@techman: This is the way it works, the guards, solicitor’s/barrister’s, DPP office and Judges all depend on bad people to do bad thing so they can get paid a hansom some. If they keep all these people locked or give harsh sentences to deter would be criminals our legal system and its gravy train wont exist.
@Jamie Jj Tobin: you’re getting stupider and stupider every time you open your mouth
@Ohhh_reeally: can you explain the lenient sentence and large compo rewards the legal system in this country have ever day then? Any normal person would swear they want the courts full of people every day!
@Jamie Jj Tobin: how does that benefit the gardaí? At the district court level outside of Dublin, all court business is handled by either an inspector or superintendent and the individual gardaí don’t attend until the hearing. The situation in Dublin is almost identical, save for the fact that a sergeant is court instead of an inspector. It’s not as if they are making overtime off the backs of giving people bail. It also flies in the face of the fact that gardaí object to bail.
Who let’s these people out on bail??? The judges not the gardai… all these problems lie with the courts letting them out on bail, not enough prison space to keep them on on remand and the fact that they are entitled to take up bail and have it granted for most offences…. how could this be the fault of gardai ?
The massive elephant in the room is the legal aid system and the massive amounts of money the legal profession makes from it. The revolving door bail system guarantees repeated court appearances and multiple payouts for solicitors. There is no way the state will get the better of the lawyers and tough luck to the public.
Why are all the comments about 2 cyclists when the heading is about Varadkar and the supply and confidence agreement ?
Sure we need room in our prisons for tv licence offenders.
I saw his mother on the telly last night. How many convictions does a person have to rack up in this country to be given a long prison sentence.
It’s a shame and joke for families have to fight for justice in Ireland. The gardas are covering up there mistakes. The family has to suffer.
@Cos Sullivan: You’re probably just another fake account. What mistake are they covering up? He has been arrested numerous times, taken to court and let go by a judge, what do you want the Gardai to do?
@B9xiRspG: The gardai have a very big say who gets bail. The judge ask the gardai about his criminal history and do they have any objections to bail.
@Cos Sullivan: you obviously don’t attend courts much. Go to the high Court in cloverhill any day bail cases are been heard and educate yourself
@Cos Sullivan: indeed they do; and in the vast majority of cases, the courts ignore garda objections and grant bail. Even where bail is denied by the district court, the accused person can apply to the high court who will then overturn the district court’s decision more often than not. It is hard to keep someone on remand in this country.
Translation: let’s keep this cushy arrangement going because we’re very unpopular at the moment and mightn’t survive an election.
Are the comments below related to the story above?
@Patabake Kennedy: Is dona linn an briseadh seo… Journal editor has just fallen asleep.
If Martin extends the agreement then he can kiss bye bye to the FF party
@P Quinn: Agree. Time for a GE. Martin might as well run for FG if he can’t figure that out.
Confidence & supply – Jesus wept. It’s a con job supplying the inept pro political hacks in Fianna Gael with massive salaries & all the perks going to enable their rich mates prosper. Can anyone explain how either party differs from the other? No? Thought so – they are two sides of the same self serving coin. Awful.
@Setrakian
Fianna Gael – no such party. Will you explain the difference between SF and the IRA.
Parents please don’t let your children cycle on Irish roads. Especially in cities and large towns – the risk is too great.
GSOC, independent ? Really ?
Nice to see my comment about the harsh reality of contributory negligence has been deleted. Clearly facts on court cases, and the legal standing of tribunals and inquiries aren’t welcome around here
the gardai gave him own bail 4 times
Absolute rubbish to say “had the Gardai been told of the offence in the north he would not have been out”
It’s next to impossible to get someone remanded in custody once the apply for bail. If the first court doesn’t let them out the high Court almost always will
Fianna fail need to grow a pair
Do you rem
If someone commits a crime they should be arrested and put in a jail cell. Not allowed back on the streets. And this man should be deported. The Gardai could learn from the UK police, they do not allow the law to be broken. They take action.
They need to get this enquiry going ASAP and stop chatting about it
I think i cliked on finegeal.com by accident.
No! the blatant disregard for interalia cyclists, by drivers who look at their phones, or back at their screaming kids, while driving has to be stopped, as it has been in all other European countries bar this one…
Moving on swift Lee……breaking news Big High Hen Shaw of Galway Cultural Gig has resigned….apparentently a lot of the Petrie dishes went missing…….get it!!!!!!!!
The sooner these two become one the better.
have your say