Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
This article was first published at 10.29pm, 18 July
AN OFFICIAL REPORT into how children in direct provision system feel about their circumstances has found that some have been the victims of racism while others complain about “overcrowded” and “dirty” conditions.
Researchers from the Child Law Clinic at University College Cork carried out the research and spoke to children in the direct provision system aged between 8-17.
Among the issues the children pointed to were the length of time they are forced to stay in the direct provision system. A number of children said they have lived in the system since they were born.
Others say they have been victimised because they live in direct provisions and face racism in school.
Other children said they feel unsafe having to live in the same centres as single men.
Direct provision centres house asylum applicants and their families while applications are being processed but the conditions in which the people are held and the length of time they are required to stay there has been frequently criticised.
The report states that while some of the children spoke about “the amazing community” there,
the majority of those consulted are highly critical of what they state are the “overcrowded” and “dirty” conditions under which they are forced to live for long periods of time. They say that they do not like the system, that it is “not fair”, “not safe,” and that they are frequently subjected to rudeness and insensitive treatment by staff (including security staff) and by adults living in the centres.
The report also states that “racism and stigma was an underlying theme” that ran through the children’s testimonies with some describing instances of both implicit and explicit racism.
In one instance, a child aged 8-12 years describes feeling picked on in school by a teacher:
And our school, our teacher, my teacher shouts at me more than – my teacher doesn’t love me more than – she likes the other kids instead of me. There’s another girl from Romania that gets like that, bullied.
Some children also said they disliked being called “refugees and asylum seekers” by staff or by other residents who have already got their papers.
Food
The report also states that a recurring theme among the children and young people consulted was an unhappiness with the quality of the food they are provided with in their direct provision centres.
The diets were described in various disparaging ways such as, “horrible and disgusting”, “always the same” and “the food has no taste,” according to the report.
A number of children mentioned that they were not allowed to cook their own food so always had to eat Irish or Polish cooking by staff at the centres.
“The food is not good – we eat Irish food and drink – they should cook African food or let us do it ourselves,” one child aged between 8-12 told the researchers.
Another complaint from the children was a lack of space for play and recreation with some pointing out that common areas were regularly occupied by single men.
“We do not get to use the room where there is two pool tables and a big TV because the men are always there,” said one child aged between 8-12 years.
“There is so many men, and coz they look creepy look at you,” another child aged 13-18 said.
Reaction
The report was welcomed by Minister for Justice Charlie Flanagan who said hearing the voices of children will help direct policy.
“This report is an important contribution to our policy development in this area and the stories of children and young people living in State-provided accommodation continue to contribute to the ongoing improvements in services in accommodation centres,” the minister said.
Others have reacted less positively, however. Tanya Ward of the Children’s Rights Alliance said that it is of “deep concern” that some children feel unsafe in direct provision centres.
“The safety and welfare of children in direct provision cannot be compromised any longer,” she stated.
“A dedicated child protection and welfare strategy needs to be developed and implemented immediately as the Children’s Rights Alliance has been calling for some time. ”
The report can be read in full here.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Sizeable fines OR Community Work should be imposed, along with deductions from salary/dole to go towards replacement of equipment.
@Me Me: not going to happen, the law only applies to law abiding citizens. If they’ve no fear of being caught, then there is no deterrent to stop them doing what their doing.
@Electro Box: Ireland loves privatising once government bodies… they should do that with prisons.
@P. V. Aglue: it’s getting to the point that the social contract we have with those in authority is crumbling. No one trusts that dep of justice the guards or other government departments will or can do anything. Might as well employ vigilantes to go after these people
I am sorry to hear that such occurred. Ireland isn’t the Ireland that I grew up in. Give me back the 70s and 80s again. We may have had nothing, but next door had little more, if that. And I fear that this is just the start of it.
6 individuals, I bet my house on it, that the nationality comes into question. But of course, even if caught, it won’t be made public, we wouldn’t want to show up those who give out the social welfare payments to the group. And still, there isn’t enough here so open up, let’s increase the population a little bit more, for the next 5 years. Put more strain on resources, watch the Irish die due to the lack of care/support but that doesn’t matter as long as we keep Europe happy. May as well scrap the Irish constitution and slap us with the European one. I digress
@John Aherne: get outta here with that sentimental claptrap. We had a police force, courts and prisons in the 70’s and 80’s, as I recall. They weren’t standing around doing nothing waiting for crime to reach Ireland
@John Aherne: word salad and you seems to think the solution is simple. It isn’t. What a time to be alive !
@offside again: What a time to be alive – Yeah, especially if you win the AHB lottery and get a €600-800k home for nothing from our housing quangos + the state pays to rear your kids.
Not so good if you’re a regular couple that want to buy a home and do the right things – then you’re bidding against government quangos + foreign and Irish investors and end up paying over 1/2 a million for a crummy ex corpo house.
@Electro Box: the country is mismanaged, no doubt about it.
It’s run by Irish people. So work that one out …
@John Aherne: Absolutely spot on John… but sssshhhh as we’ll appear as far right racists.
@offside again: Use a logical approach to resolving it to some degree, hard work, and keep on top of the foundation that has been laid down. Nobody mentioned that it was going to be simple. But, seeing your comment along with another, simple does show face, but I would never kick simple when it thinks it’s an enthusiastic time to be alive.
@Donna Fallon: Thank you, Donna. I’ll be sure to keep sssshhhh on it. It’ll be our little secret. Many thanks for the tip.
Racist, if we were all to be cut, we bleed the same colour. I see nothing racist in that (the latter for those who deem me one)
@Ronan Mc: One day, you might even make sense. Another day, you may complete a sentence.
@John Aherne: what ?
@Ronan Mc: Yes, and Dublin is very safe, Helen McEntee said so!
@John Aherne: what are you in all that is not mighty talking about? Have you ever lived near Aungier Street? No you haven’t because I know by reading your nonsense you have not. It’s always had burglaries, it’s always had muggings, it’s always had a lot of issues with “our own” crowd even if this was carried out by non-nationals. You are so deluded if you think you know our city centre.
@John Aherne: lads come on. Only a few months ago. All these morans as u call them. Where re elected by us the irish people. And we will continue to do so. So we have made our bed as we always do. So now we must lie in the it.
@John Flanagan: Now, with that, I concur. The definition of insanity
@TheGood Feign: By your definition, Dublin is indeed a kip. I concur. And you are correct, I do not live in the kip, nor would I want to live in the kip. Your city center has been all over the news, not in a good light. I believe the best part of “your city” can be viewed in the rear view mirror of a car. Deluded I am not, I am well aware of the fact that “your city” is a kip, as to which you have confirmed, confirmation that wasn’t needed, but keyboard warriors will do what keyboard warriors do. You think, therefore, you are!
@Ronan Mc: well they were letting the Catholic Church get away with literally anything for decades so…
@Electro Box:There is no fault in anything that you mentioned. Those in government, although not my first choice, what is the alternative. SF would bring this country to its knees, in my opinion. So we are stuck at the moment with what we have. There is no point in having the Taliban coffee mornings so to bitch about what’s going on, health, housing, immigration etc etc. As for religion, it has done nothing but cause wars. The “good book”, in that, the man upstairs has killed in the millions, the guy downstairs, less than a dozen. The freakish ideas of Lotts two daughters, the toying with Abraham to sacrifice his son, and this is in the same faith. Now mix cultures, and see what you get. I am glad to be an evolutionist. Recently, I read an article here, Valentines Day stabbing. Go figure
@John Aherne: you missed the gang violence on the 70S and the crime caused by heroin addiction in the 80s. Dublin is far safer today
@JoeJoe Kilbride: Dublin is far safer now, er, um, is that the line from the previous minister for justice, as she walked aided by Garda on either side of her? Do you have such security with you, seeing that you’d be quite comfortable to venture through the streets and lanes of the city. I did not miss the violence of those decades, but if memory serves me, it was Dublin, the “goodfeign guys Dublin,” that was affected. And it spread through the country thereafter, and today, we can see how bad the country is with all that stuff and more. You can keep your city, and I’ll extend the border to the county itself, and I’ll stick to my piece of the country. I know which is on the news a lot more, and it isn’t here where I am located.
@John Aherne: There was a documentary on about Hutch the last two weeks and it featured Dublin City centre and the crime sprees these gangs went on in the 70s and 80d and everything about it, the city in particular looked grim. Not to mention the mass emigration of the time. Everyone seems to look back at everything through rose tinted glasses. That said I don’t know why the book just isn’t thrown at these people when caught.
@John Moore: Rose tinted vision, I again find myself in agreement. At the time, the West was not affected, and Dublin was in the media at the time. When it wasn’t on my doorstep, it could easily be dismissed as, ” That’s up there, not here.” But, bejaysus, did it spread throughout the country like wildfire. Within the court system, logic has no place inside those doors. The truth has no place inside those doors. It’s the best story that wins. With a judicial system like that, revolving door syndrome occurs, Gardaí at a loss as to what to do, when all of their hard work counts for nothing. Two things that haven’t improved in the last 40 years are, 1. the legal system, and the 2nd, the health system.
@TheGood Feign: I’m just listening to radio 1, American tourists in an airbandb circa Pearce Street. Some guy comes in at 12.30 am while they’re watching TV. Wearing a bala and bringing his trusty knife with him, proceeded to take said TV off the wall, he then creates a comedy of errors (he must be a Dub) trying to get out with TV under his arm. What a lovely kip to live in!
Suspect in fatal stabbing of Quham Babatunde on South Anne Street was on bail for violent incident involving knife.
@Chris: if true,I’m not a bit surprised.
@Chris: But But there’s no unvetted people coming into the country the government said, seems like alot of these asylum seekers are running for justice elsewhere, one arrested today in Belfast running back to the UK, I wonder where else he ran from, why aren’t the media naming those arrested, trying to hide shit from people again at the request of the government I suppose.
Horrible to see this happen, but are you seriously telling me that 300€ in a tip jar was left there overnight?
@Electro Box: That’s fair, but those jars are emptied and divided at end of day. They may leave some change in for next day.
The Government are far too soft on people who are found guilty of theft/burglary. You read about people being convicted and it says it is their 10th conviction or whatever number you want to choose.
There is absolutely no deterrent, because they are likely to either get off for a first offence, or they get a very short sentence. And if they do get a sentence, they only serve half of it.
Then you have all these civil liberty type, do gooders that says prison does not work. You have to look at the causes of them stealing. Yes of course you do but there should be far stiffer sentences for those who commit crimes.
It is ridiculous that the guards spend so much time and resources in actually catching some offenders, and then the judge lets them off. Only for them to reoffend.
It is wokeism at its best, even though I hate using that term. Simon Harris is a perfect example of this, coming on and condemning crimes but doing absolutely nothing that will deter them.
@Joseph Fitzgibbon: We have to bring in 3 strikes laws. Mandatory sentence after three strikes should be automatic ten years. Same for 14-18 year olds
@Bingbangbong: Unfortunately you know, I know, we all know that that is not going to happen. They have rights, no responsibilities, only rights. Sad that it’s come to this.
@Bingbangbong:
Absolutely.
The toe rags will never change.
They are incapable of working for a wage,and probably have no education,or qualifications.
5 yrs in jail should be the norm for persistent crimes.
Their mugshot displayed so that people can protect their property.
The guards arrived half an hour later, no rush, lads
@N D K: no rush,that’s a decent response by today’s standards.
Past time to start deporting,we have gangs of criminal immigrants carrying knives !! Wakey Wakey Ireland ! Any sign of mehole Martin and his pet fly Harris ? Off interfering in Ukraine or gaze no doubt
@Electro Box: I lived in Dublin north inner city mid to late 80s as a student and in my first jobs. Great craic but it was always a bit dodgy. Shortest way back was by the Ilac Center, often populated by ciderheads and glue sniffers.
And into the mix throw the criminals’ friend, judge you NO… who, & we all know precisely what’s going to happen. Absolutely NOTHING meaningful. What an expensive waste.
Two burglaries in their current premises and they moved from Denmark Sweet because of raids there. Just awful
Whats so wrong with lengthy sentences and building a new super prison as planned 25 years ago? Are we in denial about crime and punishment by trying to help the poor offenders? Time for action.
Time to follow DIRTY HARRY approach to these detritus as custodial sentences appear to be not working
If the Gardai don’t get off their arses soon someone will be killed, either innocent citizens or some of the feral youths roaming around!
have your say