Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
JUSTICE MINISTER CHARLIE Flanagan has told the Dáil that there are no grounds for another investigation into the Stardust Tragedy.
A total of 48 people died and 214 people were injured in the fire that engulfed the Stardust nightclub in Artane, north Dublin, in the early hours of Valentine’s Day, 14 February 1981.
Earlier this year, retired judge Pat McCartan was tasked with examining potential new evidence into the tragedy. He ruled that a new inquiry was not warranted, saying there was no new evidence.
In the aftermath of the fire, a tribunal of inquiry was set up under Justice Ronan Keane. However, a committee of victims’ families rejected the findings which said arson was the “probable cause” of the fire which began in the west alcove.
The Stardust Relatives and Victims Committee has also rejected McCartan’s review and has demanded a full commission of inquiry.
Speaking in the Dáil last night, Flanagan said that there is nothing more the government can do.
He said that McCartan informed the Department of Justice that he was in receipt of late material from the Committee after he had already concluded his report.
“Despite having completed his report, Judge McCartan looked at the additional material sent to him. The judge subsequently informed my department that this additional material did not constitute new evidence. As a result, the judges report finding stands,” Flanagan said.
The government has fulfilled its commitment in relation to assessing the new evidence. Accordingly, it does not believe any further investigation will provide the answers the committee is seeking.
‘I sympathise’
Flanagan said that he understood that the victims’ committee is disappointed with the outcome of the independent assessment process.
“I acknowledge that Judge McCartan’s report does not provide the outcome that the committee was seeking, in finding that no commission of investigation is warranted,” he said.
I would like, once again, to sympathise with the committee and all of the families affected by the Stardust fire.
I understand that each of you will never forget this terrible tragedy and will carry heartbreaking loss and memories with you for the rest of your lives.
Also speaking in the Dáil last night, Minister of State Finian McGrath offered his sympathies to the families affected.
“The Stardust fire is one of the greatest disasters in the history of this state and is seared into the collective members of all residents of the Northside. It had, and continues to have, a devastating impact on survivors, friends and family members of those killed and injured,” McGrath said.
McGrath acknowledged the decision made by McCartan, but noted the mention of Stardust on page 107 of the Programme for a Partnership Government, which reads: “Full regard will be had to any new evidence which emerges which would be likely to definitely establish the cause of the fire at Stardust.”
McGrath said: “As far as I’m concerned, and as long as the government is in place, the line contained in the Programme for a Partnership regarding [Stardust] still stands.
“I too sympathise with the committee, and all affected families, for the loss they have suffered as a result of the Stardust tragedy.
“I commend the committee for its search for answers and the support it has provided to the families concerns over a number of decades.”
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Long overdue. Europe needs to stand with oppressed people around the world. Democracy and fundamental civil rights are the only way forward for humanity
Religion the cause of oppression and wars since time began,
@Paul Crowley: I’m an atheist but can see that Religions themselves can be a great cornerstone for morality and guidance for communities and nations. Many people use them peacefully as a way to live their life with love and respect for their fellow man.
The Problem is that they have been weaponised by power hungry despots the world over to strip people of their rights and belongings for centuries.
@Paul Crowley: the separation of church and state is essential and should be carefully protected,the demonising of individual belief systems however is just a sure way to cause division.
@Paolo Fandango: The fundamental problem with most religions is that they are a means by which men can force people (and especially women) to live their lives the way they think they should be lived.
This is how you end up in mad situation where the answer to men’s weakness and jealousy is to force women to cover up everything that causes the weakness and jealousy i.e it’s women’s fault and problem, not men’s.
And before Christians get too sanctimonious it’s not that long since Irish women had to wear ankle length dresses and headscarves to cover up all the tempting bits.
@Stanley Marsh: well spotted. Ireland in the decades after independence wasn’t far off what Iran is today. The only difference is we shoveled our women and children into institutions
@Paul Crowley: Yes one religion is still centuries behind the civilized world in the west . In fact its going backwards not forward
America has its Evangelicals and Afghanistan has its Taliban.
@andrew: I don’t think Evangelicals behead who they seem to have sinned or stone women to death for being in their view promiscuous, among other benign “sins”?
@catinthehat: Only because US laws won’t allow it.
@Stanley Marsh: the US still executes people though
@Stanley Marsh: that’s why the absolute separation of church and state is so vital. Ireland is still slowly crawling out from under the Catholic church
have your say