We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
AN BORD PLEANÁLA has ordered a developer to preserve by photographic record graffiti at one of the best-known sites for street art in Dublin.
In a novel condition attached to giving the go-ahead for demolishing the Tivoli Theatre in Dublin’s Liberties area and replacing it with a five-storey, 289-bed ‘aparthotel’, the appeals board has inserted the ‘graffiti condition’.
The planning go-ahead will mean the destruction of the walls where the graffiti is present at the site.
The car park at the site has been decorated by graffiti artists and the board inspector in the case, Karla McBride, stated that the artists’ work “is emblematic of 21st century European urban youth culture and some of the art is to a high standard”.
In one of the 16 conditions attached to the permission, the board has ordered that owner of the Tivoli, Anthony Byrne, preserve the graffiti art contained within the site by photographic record which, it says, should be undertaken by a professional photographer.
The board has ordered that a written and digital report containing the results of the photographic survey shall be submitted to the city council for distribution to public libraries in the city.
The insertion of the condition comes against the background of Dublin City Council spending around €1 million a year removing graffiti around the city.
The decision by An Bord Pleanála in giving the aparthotel the go-ahead overturns a decision made by the city council, which refused planning permission for the development last year.
Theatre owner, Anthony Byrne, was seeking permission to level the 1930s building – which he has operated since 1981 – and build an aparthotel with a gym, restaurant and bicycle-hire shop on the site.
Performance space
Conservation charity An Taisce expressed concerns that the closure of the Tivoli Theatre would constitute a regrettable loss for the social and cultural life of the area and the wider city. People Before Profit councillor Tina MacVeigh also opposed the plan.
The new plan is to incorporate a new performance space of 367 sq m to accommodate cultural performances, while an outdoor performance space and cinema space would also be provided.
In its decision, the appeals board has ordered the omission of the fifth floor of the planned development in the interests of visual amenity.
The appeals board gave the plan the go-ahead after finding that “the proposed development would not seriously injure the amenities of the area or of property in the vicinity and would not adversely affect the setting of the nearby protected structures”.
In the appeal lodged to the board on Byrne’s behalf, it argued that the 500-seat Tivoli receives no Arts Council funding and doesn’t have sufficient capacity to be viable, unlike the 1,000-people capacity Vicar Street.
The appeal argued that the current building is in relatively poor condition due to unviability and does not contribute significantly to the quality of the street.
The appeal also stated that the redevelopment would eliminate the Dublin 8, late night venue, which it said has been an alleged source of nuisance.
Written by Gordon Deegan and posted on Fora.ie
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Shame. I go there monthly, there are very few performance spaces of that size in Dublin.
I’m delighted to see the Graffiti being preserved. Beats another tacky Spar being at the base of the building. One of the things I love about Berlin and other cosmopolitan cities is they can integrate art and architecture. Drury buildings is a good but modest example here in Dublin.
@Brian Sean M: There will just be a photo record of the Graffiti in the hotel
@Brian Sean M: it’s not being preserved just photographed…
@Paul Comerford:
A Tivoli Tapestry might have more longevity and be good for business.
Another nightclub gone so. Government places no value on the protection of these venues and their value to the night time economy.
Brilliant another gym and characterless building in Dublin, good job. Saw the beastie boys play there in mid 90′s great gig.
@Barra O Brien: Did you even 2nd paragraph. i know were all here for the comments but come on Barra brah
Shocking eyesore.
Isnt this place now used as district 8?
Such a shame :) I remember the manic street preachers there in October 1993, James Dean Bradfield did a great version on his white Gibson les Paul of ‘rain drops keep falling on my head’ being Welsh of course he would of known weather we liked it or not lol hence the my comment 25 years later lol
District 8 for all the cool cats be gone now too – will have no where else to go other than Hanger which will be shutting up shop soon enough too. Nightlife in Dublin is a farse.
Even SIN is gone – the poor rolex (no papers required) wearing, gucci tshirts and LV shoes will have nowhere to buy their bottles of vodka from the social, be staying in drinking in mammys box room on York Street.
OTT Wrestling and District 8 are great nights there. Hope they find a good home. Stevie wonder has more vision than our city planners/council!
WTF! no more Sammy Sausages & Buffy! Heartbreaking news
More sloppy writing. Do you mean knocked DOWN?
Just what Dublin/Ireland needs in the middle of a housing crisis yet another hotel! I’ve been documenting by camera the graffiti created by artists from here and all over the world up there for the last 4 years. Sad day!
have your say