Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE COST OF providing “out-of-cycle” smear tests is €9.6million, the Department of Health confirmed to the Public Accounts Committee today.
In an attempt to strengthen trust in the CervicalCheck programme, Health Minister Simon Harris announced last year that women who had received a free smear test could get a repeat done. This offer was available between May and December last year.
Concerns about the programme had been raised after 221 women who had been diagnosed with cervical cancer in the past 10 years were not told that their past smear tests had been audited, and it was found that they had been interpreted incorrectly.
As a result of the government’s offer for repeat smear tests, there was a surge in demand for the CervicalCheck programme, and this led to a massive backlog in results being received. Waiting times for results increased from 2-4 weeks to a maximum of 27 weeks, according to the HSE.
Healthcare professionals, GPs, cytology units and politicians have raised concerns about the decision to offer repeat smear tests to the public without allocating additional resources to it.
Oireachtas Health Committee chair Michael Harty, who is also a Clare GP said that “if the offer of out-of-cycle smears was to reassure women, it certainly hasn’t done that… and has undermined people’s confidence in the CervicalCheck programme”.
Previous media reports had indicated before that the spending for repeat smear tests would be around €10 million. Today, the breakdown was confirmed as:
GPs received €49 from the government as payment for carrying out the free repeat smear tests.
Committee appearance today
Appearing before PAC today, secretary general of the Department of Health Jim Breslin said that on 11 December, he advised the Committee of costs associated with GP consultation fees and the taking of repeat smear tests associated with this decision.
At that time I advised that the combination of GP consultations, smear taking and laboratory costs were likely to be well within a total estimate of €10 million to year-end.
He also said that the Minister for Health made the decision to provide for a free out-of-cycle smear tests for “any woman who was concerned, where her GP felt she should have a further test as part of her reassurance”.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
10 million, a drop in the ocean for the incompetent politician capable of wasting billions.
Very loose use of the word “free”.
Mistakes shouldn’t have happened in the first place. It’s obviously the right decision for the state to cover the costs.
I cant see why the government wouldn’t take legal action against the outsouced company for the mistakes though?.
@Steve O’Reilly: because they weren’t mistakes. Google or Wikipedia screening and learn about false negatives
So.
But it’s free, how can it cost anything?
@sb: The staff don’t work for free and shouldn’t be expected to.
Who cares what it costs it should be done.
So what? That’s the problem with this country it’s all about the money
Free. When the politicians say something is free, they mean the taxpayer paid. And if something is free, it is wide open to abuse and wastage. Thats how our useless politicians view taxpayers money.
10 million is a small price to pay considering 18 women lost their lives.
Worth every cent for the women of this country just sorry that it was as a result of shocking care for others that highlighted the need for it all to be retaken
Worth every red cent, if it has saved even 1 life. It scares me to think of what the alternative would’ve been, had those brave women affected not spoken up to potentially save others.
have your say