Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
As members of the Green Party, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil debate the merits of the new programme for government, the leaders of the Greens arguably have the toughest task getting the deal over the line, with two-thirds of the party’s membership needed to carry the proposal.
As the battle for the hearts and minds of the Irish green movement begins, we invited two representatives with opposing views to state their case. RISE TD for Dublin South-West, Paul Murphy has written a letter to Green Party members asking them to reject the deal, while here, Green MEP Ciarán Cuffe says this is an armistice moment that must be grasped:
WHAT CAN YOU actually achieve in politics? For an ideologically-driven party like the Greens, it is a question we consider every day. Sure, we all want to save the planet, and bring about a just transition, but what changes can you actually achieve within the constraints of Government? Opposition is easy, but Government is tough, particularly for smaller parties like ourselves.
Every vote, every amendment, and every decision is a series of compromises. The draft programme for government ‘Our Shared Future’ reflects those choices. However, from a Green party perspective, there is a lot to like.
A commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 51% over the coming decade would be a huge achievement, and although it still would not align with what climate science dictates, it would show the world what can be done. A commitment to retrofitting 500,000 homes to a B2 energy rating by 2030 would be extraordinary.
Timing is everything and with the arrival of Covid-19, it’s obvious now that these are not normal times. As the pandemic struck, the European Investment Bank announced that they would end financing for fossil fuel energy projects from the end of next year.
A new departure for a new normal
Some of the language in the draft programme is transformational: ending Direct Provision; providing cost rental housing; and spending €360m a year on walking and cycling. The adoption of these measures would be timely, but other measures such as the provision of free contraception for women aged 17-25, and ‘baby boxes’ to all new parents underscores the role of the state in taking care of its citizens.
A lesson from the Covid-19 crisis is that the State can and should assist its people in providing services that are needed. A focus on public health, public transport, and public housing is required as we move to a new normal dictated by these extraordinary times.
None of this will happen overnight. There are of course areas where we didn’t succeed in negotiations, but that is inevitable given the Green Party’s representation in the Dáil. There’s a lot of commitments to reviews rather than actions, but that can be the start of effecting change.
We are still in mid-crisis, and rebooting our economy within the health constraints of the pandemic will be hugely challenging. If our membership decides that we should enter Government (and the bar is set high at two-thirds support of our voting membership) there will be difficult calls to make in the coming months and years.
However, if we sit at the cabinet table we have a voice and take part in the decision-making process. I accept that if you’re in opposition you can provoke debate, and on occasion bring about change.
No time to ‘hurl from the ditch’
With interest rates the lowest in living memory, now is the time to borrow to invest in a low-carbon future. Bord na Móna announced on Tuesday that it will suspend peat harvesting activities and prioritise peat rehabilitation. Meanwhile, the EU has trebled its funding for a ‘Just Transition’ in coal and peat extraction regions. That means more green jobs.
This is an armistice moment that must be grasped. These opportunities happen at best once a decade. When the planet is burning, it is not a time to argue over the colour of the fire engine.
We can seize the opportunity of the European Green Deal, announced by the Commission last year. It lays out plans to make Europe the first carbon-neutral continent by 2050. We need to embrace this opportunity for low-carbon employment, or we can wait for a progressive political alliance that may never emerge.
As an MEP I can see that the language of politics is changing: the circular economy is now centre-stage; zero pollution and low-carbon solutions permeate our discussions, and the Sustainable Development Goals inform our debates.
There is a golden opportunity here to marry climate action with social justice, and while the text of the programme isn’t perfect, it allows us to take action on issues that we have campaigned on for years. There are commitments to more protection for renters; to enacting hate crime legislation; and a new National Action Plan Against Racism. Such measures can bring about a fairer Ireland.
There is an extraordinary opportunity to be seized now in 2020, where the Green Party can make real the ideas that we believe in, and take responsibility for changing the world. We should grasp this moment and enter government.
In the words of Barack Obama’s former Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel: “You never let a serious crisis go to waste. And what I mean by that is it’s an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before.”
Ciarán Cuffe is a Green Party MEP for Dublin. You can read the full programme for government here.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
I’ll be voting for change.
SF.
@Willy Mc Entire:
Keep dreaming Sinn Fein will never be in government
@Just Some Guy: they will though not this time but in the coming years they will weather you like it not
@Just Some Guy: I reckon ffg have become so arrogant and look at peeps in Ireland as if ye we can keep taking the piss to a certain extent but they’ve pushed their luck, maybe not this year but 5 next election if SF play their cards right should have a margority so putting an end to this 100 years of wo cheeks of the same arse arguing over who farted, the main party leaders are blunt along with RTE
@Just Some Guy:
Sinn Fein have been Government in the past.
The originators of both FF & FG were once Sinn Fein (1919-1921)
and as such formed the first Dail !
@Willy Mc Entire: how will have SF done in running the North with the DUP all these years.
@Bobby wilson: different kettle of fish
@Emer Caffrey: why would that be Emer? Are the Water charges abolished? SF were v strong on that issue in the 26.
@Willy Mc Entire: change with SF. Dream on. I think their social media campaigns have worked…
100,000 houses over 5 years and all that promised infrastructure for 10bn. Funniest thing I read In Years…. wouldn’t even get all those promised train lines for that amount. The children’s hospital quantity surveyor must have got another gig.
@Bobby wilson: The two are as comparable as chalk and cheese. The north is a power sharing executive and have no opposition bench. But SF, by bringing down the institutions, allowed things to happen that couldn’t be agreed to by the DUP. Namely marriage equality, pro choice and an Irish language act. Fact of the matter is the DUP tried to play hard and when that failed they returned to Stormont to cling on to the little power they have in UK politics.
@Willy Mc Entire: Sinn Fein/IRA won’t be in this year for sure.
@Emer Caffrey: sorry but SINN FEIN where in joint power with the DUP in running the six county state with the British government pumping in billions pounds towards it. so you can’t say SF had no control on what was happening across North .
@Paul Linehan: in regards of full abortion on demand been implemented across the NORTH there is a lot anger among very large proportion of the Catholic /Nationalist population across the NORTH particularly west of the bann which we could see from the last British election.
@Sal Paradise: FF/IMF and FG/DUP will do business with whoever can keep them in power. We need a strong SF mandate to keep those parties that ruined our economy in check.
@Just Some Guy: you should never stop dreaming a chara
@Moorooka Mick: if sinn finn want be in power they need to think seriously about the leadership the present leader has done nothing to convince the majority of the country so far when she opens her mouth
@Willy Mc Entire: Very surprised SF are up this early, must be dole day.
@Pascal the Rascal: *supporters
@Conan Campbell: FG/DUP? – so wait the DUP are a terrorist organization working for FG, robbing banks,drug dealing – then giving money to FG as donations?? No way…and the IMF too?
Someone needs to make a movie when this is all done.
@Sal Paradise: Sa\y hi to the 70′s…
@Bobby wilson: Working with the DUP is like working with Iran, anyone who can actually work with those knuckle draggers needs applause..
@Just Some Guy: SF with 33 TDs for the 33 government. Dry your eyes Willy
@Willy Mc Entire: voting Ruth Coppinger no1 shes a fighter for her area in the dail
@MickN: Hi 70′s.
@Conan Campbell: Strong = Gun to the back of the head?
I’ve had Leo’s sponsored ad pop up a few times. I report it for being ‘misleading or a scam’
Sinn fein for a needed change after 100years of ffg
@Tom o brien: that’s great Tom
@Tom o brien: Account opened in Jan 2020… interesting!!
@Sal Paradise: plus he can’t spell his own name though that makes him slightly more likely to be SF.
@Ro-your-nan: That is the FFG way, talk down to those who disagree, portray them as stupid… See where is gets them…
@Ro-your-nan: nothing like personal insults to the man speaking his truth. Typical toff behaviour.
@Dermot Foley: toff? Is that a personal insult?
@Ro-your-nan: They are only personal insults when directed at SF supporters. Otherwise it’s ok.
@Sal Paradise: New account so what? His opinion is only valid to you if his account is 2 years old?
@Caoimhín O Neill: maybe Tom could clarify the situation
Bit of a misleading headline there guys. FG have spent nearly three times more than SF and FF have spent more than twice that of SF. Don’t forget who started austerity and don’t forget who continued it.
@Ebeneezer Goode: The journal engaging in a bit of covert bias, trying to make it look like SF spent as much as FG… It’s hard to win seats when the mainstream media is biased against you.
Virgin media and Newstalk are shameless in their bias against SF. Of course there is a common denominator there, Denis O’Brien. I suspect there is enough appropriate evidence, that could be gathered to prove covert bias. Dennis has a lot to lose and so have Irish society, depending on how you vote.
Could he be a shadowy influencer of FG? Of course he is but one. There are a lot of others taking advantage of the incompetents in FG & FF and we pay the price.
@Ebeneezer Goode: absolutely correct
@John O’Hara: correct
@John O’Hara:
The more the mainstream media try to snub Sinn Fein the stronger Sinn Fein get.
People are sick of ffgl and their total detachment (Not to mention the squandering of public funding , being directly involved in causing the deaths of the Women in the smear debacle , the hospital trolley crises to name but a few).
Sinn Fein may not get in this year but it’s going to happen.
Your headline is so misleading. FG have spent c. 25,000e in total, FF c. 20,000e while SF have spent less than half of each of those parties at c. 10,000e. Headline the facts instead of lumping SF in with FG/FF, please.
If it means one less leaflet in the door or sign on a lamp post then they can spend away, I’m sick of seeing dodgy politicians mugs
What a waste of money by all parties
ffg frauds out now !
FF never forget. https://youtu.be/aEIWNtb41k8
@Still-Not-News: Sinn Fein/IRA…never forget….don’t have enough time to post all the links about there recent murdering past.
Or are we supposed to forget their past but not others? Curious on that one?
@Still-Not-News: never forget the murders
@plug’s ear: We should never forget.
Sinn Fein’s social & economic policies are not far from those of Nordic countries which we admire ( + a 32 County Ireland bonus)
Many Right Wing Populists masquerade here as Capitalists with the arsets out of their trousers; much bravado since the near death experience of 2008!
@Moorooka Mick: have you forgotten about a million unionists who dont want a United ireland.
@plug’s ear: Democracy Plug. They will soon be the minority. They will be given equal status and their culture protected in a Reunited Ireland. And finally we can all move on from the abomination that is partition.
@plug’s ear: we live in a democracy and the overwhelming % of the electorate voted for the GFA. The terms on which unity will happen are quite clear and not up for negotiation. They are the bedrock on which the agreement is built. Its worrying to see FF being prepared to rip up an international treaty for votes.
Very misleading headline – SF spent €10k – we’re not stupid we see through your spin
@Emer Caffrey: is this the same Sinn who all got a substantial pay rise in the north for not showing up to work.
Did know about all the homelessness in the north.
About the crumbling health service.
Hypocrisy at its best
@plug’s ear: Except SF didn’t take that pay rise and returned it.
Haven’t we got a great shower to vote for ..what a shower of feather there own nest wasters
SF for change
They really should limit the amount of posters people can use. Eoghan Murphy could rebuild a replica of the ballymun towers twice over and still have a rake of posters left over. It’s kind of ridiculous. At least with digital posts there’s no environmental impact like with those posters.
@Keith Michael Gregg: but they’ve spent money on poster’s and Facebook adds, I wonder what the total amount is for each party…
Well fair play to them 50,000… man down the road that lives off a fiver a week for food… Their Corrupt as F***
@TJC Mc: betcha he holds 2 pints in his hands
@TJC Mc: its ‘they’re’ and how is buying advertising corrupt?
Btw, 50k combined on Facebook ads is f**k all.
@Ebeneezer Goode: no he can’t drink on his medication… why would you say that! The man is unwell with cancer!
@Ebeneezer Goode: hey maybe you should go with Fianna Gael/Fáil you assumed that we’d people have very little money to survive on they drink it instead of been ill and on a fiver a week for that that no one gives a F*** about Ya Dumb dung ya!
@Ebeneezer Goode: I see ya git 31 likes… you should spent yer day now making yourself a medal! Lol
NO MORE ELECTION POSTERS. So much plastic!
@Aido Yollom: they are recyclable so relax. Democracy is important.
Why don’t they just hire Cambridge Analytica and it’s a gaurenteed win?
I spent €10,000 on a meal out. That’s the average spend for me, Donald Trump and Prince Andrew.
That’s a fake news headline.
I’m a campaign manager. This really isn’t a lot of money when you consider what they are trying to do I.e reach voting age ppl across the country. I’m working on a campaign at the moment that is spending about the same amount trying to reach a much smaller audience. The only news I see in these figures is how low they are for the task at hand if I’m honest. Go to the UK or USA and tell them this – you’d be laughed at.
@John McSweeney:
You are correct €50K is a very small Facebook spend. Each party is paying multiples of that on printed posters. What is much more relevant re social media is , is using a very well coordinated army of individual accounts. It is very easy to obfuscate any potential spend using this method. It also attempts to skew people’s perception of the actual support for a particular party or position
The Journal.ie comments section is a good example of this. 90% of the posters on election topics here are Sinn Féin supporters. They all use a very similar commenting & replying techniques, almost as if they had been coached. You can also see a common, very robust, method on shutting down any anti Sinn Féin discussion.
I think all the other parties are way behind the curve on this one
@John McSweeney: As you can see.
@Feardorcha Ó Maolomhnaigh: or not, as the case may be
@Feardorcha Ó Maolomhnaigh:
If you are going to make up false numbers and push a false narrative then you should expect people to push back and challenge your comments.
EG .90% of commentators on the Journal are Sinn Fein supporters….you just made this number up.
The comments and reply techniques are ‘almost’ ‘coached’ and the ‘method’ is very robust’
If these claims were true ( they aren’t) then what you are saying is that there has been some very slick organising on behalf of the Sinn Fein party in terms of coaching for Social Media …and this has been so successful that now 90% of the comments are from these well trained Sinn Fein commentators which the other parties are way way behind on.
With respect – if Sinn Fein have managed to do that then they deserve greta credit for being the best organised party on the island.
Maybe consider this ( much more likely ) alternative.
Many many many ordinary people are sick to the teeth of the the big political parties who have been in confidence and supply for years yet the results are a shambolic public services like health , housing etc etc and this time they are crying out for a change – Sinn Fein is one of the better performing parties ( the next best polling after the big two ) and many people are so angry with the current state of play that they are engaging on social media and being much more vociferous in shouting down the status quo .
PS tell Mary Lou I expect a fee for doing this online SF party political broadcast on their behalf won’t you.
@Dave Hammond:
There is nothing false in it at all. If you look at the posters on here on political articles, 90% of them support Sinn Féin. This is completely at odds with Sinn Féin actual support on the ground. Sinn Féin got 13.7% of the 2016 GE first preferences and less than 10% of the first preferences in the last years local and EU elections. If they get 15% first preferences in the upcoming election, it would be a fantastic result for them.
People may have issues with the performance current government, that doesn’t mean 90% are going to vote for Sinn Féin.
Sinn Féin are centrally organised party. As you said, you have to give them credit for a very well managed campaign. I am sure you can have your own discussions with Sinn Féin’s leadership regarding your own posts if you need to.
@Feardorcha Ó Maolomhnaigh:
You cannot substantiate your 90% claim – you are just making up numbers – 8 out of 10 cats agree with you.
@Dave Hammond: All you have to do is count them. no one is saying these poster are all in an office together. But they clearly are coordinated. They also have no tolerance of anyone giving a more mainstream point of view. Have a look for terms like “blue shirt”, “loyalist”, “unionist”, west brit etc. Normal people don’t use those terms when discussing politics.
WONDER WHO’S MONEY THERE SPENDING TO PAY FOR ALL THIS… JUST ASKING????????
It’s time for people to be honest with themselves. Voting SF as if by some magic it’s going to change anything is just living in fantasy land. Why you may ask. To put it simply it’s down to numbers. SF don’t have them. They are only fielding 50% of the Candidates they would require to form a Government. And both FF and FG have both stated categorically that they will not go into Government with them. The two big parties between them are expected to take between 110 and 115 seats in a 158 seat Dail. SF is expected to take between 25 to 30 seats. Even if they managed to combine with every other small party and every Independent they would still be short by 32 to 37 Seats to form a majority. So all this talk of voting SF for change is fantasy. And people need to wake up to that reality.
@Mick.: You must be new to Irish politics Mick. FF or FG will do business with whoever can keep them in power. Pre-election posturing is the name of the game. We need a strong SF mandate to keep FFG in check.
@Conan Campbell: Did either party go into coalition in the last General Election? Or the one before that? How about the local elections?
@Mick.: Confidence and Supply is coalition lite. There is no such thing as coalitions in local councils. The parties agree among themselves to divvy up things like who’ll be mayor for each year of the council term but that’s it. In fact the whole bluster about not going into government with each other doesn’t exist at local level.
Facebook may be free but I foot the bill as a taxpayer for their nuisance ads on the platform :) Cool!
What a misuse of money by all the parties. Who’s funding these? There has been no party yet that has given a strong performance… They’re agendas have more holes than a Colander
Just so you know…..its us (the taxpayer) that pays for this whole charade. They get all sorts of expenses and so forth afterwards.
Same garbage lies/promises from all parties, probably high time we scrapped our stagnant political system and start from scratch again.
These are small numbers
have your say