We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
LAST UPDATE | 16 Feb 2021
THE VICE PRESIDENT of the European Commission has told TDs and Senators that “mistakes were made” in Brussels regarding the post-Brexit Northern Ireland protocol but that lessons have been learned and that Europe’s commitment to Ireland was not in doubt.
Maroš Šefčovič today addressed the Oireachtas Joint Committee on European Affairs, and said the commission would do its utmost to protect peace in Northern Ireland going forward.
However, despite being asked on numerous occasions, he did not outline who made the decision that caused such an outcry.
His appearance came after the controversial move from the European Commission to invoke Article 16 of the Northern Ireland protocol late last month, in a row over the supply of vaccines to Europe.
The move blindsided governments in Dublin and London, which could have meant checks between the six and 26 counties. EU officials quickly rescinded the plan the same evening and acknowledged it as a mistake.
In an interview with EuroNews’ Shona Murray yesterday, Šefčovič said that “we apologised for it, and we are sorry” in relation to the proposal to trigger Article 16, and said that there was a need to dial down “heated rhetoric” around the problems with carrying out post-Brexit checks in Northern Ireland.
Speaking before the Oireachtas Committee today, the European Commission vice president reiterated this apology while being pressed on how the decision was made and who exactly made that decision.
“The bottom line is that mistakes were made in the process and we deeply regret that,” he said.
“But in a matter of three hours, we got it right. Article 16 was never activated. I can assure you the commission has learned a lesson and the commission will do its utmost to protect the peace in Northern Ireland.”
Šefčovič said the proof that the European Commission will take the best measures going forward comes from its track record.
“I think that the best answer is our track record, unwavering support, political, economic and financial to the peace process since the Belfast agreement was signed and agreed upon,” he said. “Also the way in how we conducted the entire Brexit negotiation process.”
He said that during the entire Brexit negotiation process, Ireland was “in our minds all the time, and in our hearts”.
The top commission official said that work is ongoing with UK counterparts and Irish ministers to regarding the implementation of the Northern Ireland protocol.
“We want to listen, we want to learn, and we want to work on solutions,” Šefčovič said.
“It must be always a two-way street. We also have to recognise the fact that we knew from the beginning that the United Kingdom leaving the European Union, the Customs Union and the Single Market is a massive operation, that it’s not possible to prevent all the disruption.
We could do our best and we are working on it to minimise the negative impact on the people of Ireland and Northern Ireland. But it was quite obvious from the beginning that there will be the teething problems and I believe that we can resolve them if we work very well together.
Speaking to RTÉ News this afternoon, Foreign Affairs Minister Simon Coveney said that “Šefčovič has been a real friend of Ireland here”.
Coveney outlined that himself and Šefčovič will be meeting stakeholders on Brexit on Thursday and that the European Commission Vice President will be doing the same with Michael Gove in the context of stakeholders in Northern Ireland.
“He will then follow that up with a specialised Committee to focus on the protocol and its implementation and what flexibilities may be possible in ensuring that implementation is as smooth as possible and follow that up again by a Joint Committee probably early next week,” Coveney said.
Min for Foreign Affairs @simoncoveney reacts to EU Commission VP Maroš Šefčovič on Brexit and Northern Ireland Protocol. @rtenews pic.twitter.com/oFsMwOuPc5
— David Murphy (@davidmurphyRTE) February 16, 2021
“There’s a lot of commitment coming from Vice President Šefčovič and the European Commission to focus on the Irish issues, north and south, linked to the implementation of the protocol, to first of all ensure that it’s fully implemented by both sides and secondly to look at using the flexibilities within the confines of the protocol to the greatest extent possible to respond to genuine implementation issues that have emerged over the last six weeks,” he said.
A “colossal” mistake
Fianna Fáil Senator Lisa Chambers said that the move from the European Commission was a “colossal” mistake with huge political implications.
“What we’re trying to figure out is the events that led to the making of that decision,” she said. “When did you inform the other commissioners of your intention to invoke Article 16?”
Šefčovič said the decision came through a “primary objective” of the European Commission to make sure it got its fair share of vaccines.
“We are a major producer of vaccines in the EU,” he said. “We felt we weren’t getting our fair share. We didn’t have enough transparency over where these vaccines were going.
This was the thrust of the proposal on the table. The mistake was made… We made a mistake, we acknowledge it, we corrected it. We made a mistake but please take it into perspective how close the relationship of the EU and all member states is… and the support Ireland and Northern Ireland was always getting from the EU.
The European Commission vice president said that Europe has shown itself very loyal to Ireland and Northern Ireland, and that the Northern Ireland Protocol was the “only solution” to protect peace and stability while avoiding a hard border.
Labour’s Brendan Howlin said Europe’s previous commitments to Ireland “underscored the degree of shock” with the decision, and that the harm done “continues”.
“How can such a fundamental thing happen without political awareness of it?” Howlin asked. “Who signed off on it, politically? We need to understand that.”
Šefčovič reiterated that it was a “draft proposal that was quickly corrected”. He also said that there shouldn’t be a “blame game”.
Fianna Fáil’s Dara Calleary put it to Šefčovič that he was “splitting hairs” by saying Article 16 was never triggered, when every indication had been given that it would be.
He said it was vital for accountability to be provided over who made the order to trigger Article 16 and reassurances that it wouldn’t happen again. He said the protocol needed to be able to withstand changes in personnel at the highest levels, and that safeguards needed to put in place in this regard.
“Our job is parliamentary scrutiny,” Calleary said. “We’ve a responsibility to get to the detail of what happened on and the days leading up to 29 January. It’s not a blame game, we’re doing our job.”
Šefčovič replied that the move was made in the context of the situation concerning vaccines in Europe.
“I want to make it 100% clear that this article was never activated,” he said. “There was immediate communication between President [Ursula von der Leyen] and the Taoiseach and Minister Coveney.”
‘Early warning system’
Speaking to the same committee last week, Minister with responsibility for EU Affairs Thomas Byrne said that the government is seeking an “early warning system” on the use of Article 15 of the Northern Ireland protocol on Brexit.
He said the government is continuing to engage on multiple levels with the European Commission and the UK Government to find a resolution.
Byrne added: “What the Government wants fundamentally is an early warning system to be put in place.
“There is a view, and it’s a risky view, that, yes, the Commission made a mistake, yes the Commission acknowledged its mistake, and that is everything solved now.
“Clearly that’s not the case because the consequences of this are continuing.”
Asking questions today, Fine Gael TD Neale Richmond asked about the “crucially important” early warning system.
“Everyone can make mistakes but it’s how you learn from them that’s important,” he said.
Šefčovič said that a new mechanism was being set up within the Commission that would respect fully the elements of the Northern Ireland protocol while keeping all parties informed of developments.
“Ireland will always be consulted on these issues,” he added.
The European Commission vice president added that the responsibility for shortages of any supplies to supermarkets in Northern Ireland rests with the UK, as such problems were foreseen well in advance.
He said the protocol was the solution that would solve these problems in future, and that any problems with it should be ironed out.
With reporting by Hayley Halpin and Press Association
What is Article 16, what does it mean and why has it been causing so much hassle? That’s what we explored last week’s episode of The Explainer – listen below or wherever you get your podcasts.
The Explainer / SoundCloud
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
And again the EU says it was a mistake. And again, how many here will not let it go!
@Paul Furey: And it is also protecting a political master. It’s a fair question to ask who is that in the interests of transparency.
@Paul Furey: I think everybody pretty much acknowledges that this was a genuine error in judgement. Having said that, we have every right to ask who exactly made that decision as we would have been affected more than any other EU state. I’m very much pro EU but we deserve a better answer than “mistakes were made”.
@Paul Furey: ah shur we’ve all had a few pints on a night out and accidentally threw up a border in a country where no one can vote for us or remove us from office. Could happen to a saint so it could.
@Sean Oige: It was only a draft proposal. A commissioner (civil servant) drafted a suggestion that was never activate which would suggest it was never sent for political approval or was rejected as an option at a political level.
@Francis Devenney: if you believe that… It was a probing exercise designed to measure how much political power the EU currently has post Brexit, quickly withdrawn when it attracted international outrage and derision.
@Paul Furey: It is a reasonablle request for the person who made the mistake to be identified and removed from office immediately.
@Paul Furey: I’ve noticed your comments rarely focus on the article but rather on other commenters or what they might say.
@JedBartlett: he probably doesn’t read the article just comes on board for the banter!
@Valthebear: you should probably take off that tin foil hat from time to time
being from Germany, and knowing Ursula’s MO a bit, I have to admit that it seems quite likely it was her call, her mistake and she now instructed her second in command to deflect blame away from her. obviously, this is speculation, and I don’t think the blame game will lead anywhere. but it would fit in with her usual approach to things, unfortunately.
@Julian Friesel: @Julian Friesel: I think many of your fellow citizens were glad to see the back of her. The EU will continue to make such blunders as long as it is seen as a place to send politicians who fail at home.
It might be the most public example of the EU mask slipping and showing how much they really think of Ireland’s interests but it’s not the only one. The EU insistence on pointless regulations and tariffs now see ireland disproportionately effected. From bread prices rising due to tariffs to everyone here now being charged tariffs etc on Amazon orders even if the items originate in another eu country but are handled through the U.K. , the whole deal is a joke. The U.K. /EU deal was made unnecessarily difficult by the EU wish to make an example of the U.K. and put off any other country from leaving. That same spiteful mentality led to the article 16 debacle.
@Sara Davis: No, it’s called protected the single market, on whose integrity our economy depends on. The U.K. left , it was not throw out so now it is been treated as a third country . You can’t have it both ways
@Sara Davis: I wish I could find a video but there was somebody at the start of all this I think the guy with a French accent who said we will just put a border… He literally have not got a clue about the situation on our beautiful island.
@Sara Davis: needless regulation and tariffs? I think you need to research how global trade works, and how legislation and standards differ between jurisdictions. It feels strange repeating this analogy four years later, but the UK chose to leave the club. They cannot expect to retain the benefits of club membership.
@Sara Davis:
Think of it like a divorce but the UK still wants conjugal rights.
@Sara Davis: the border in Ireland is the fault of one country: England.
Think we all know a stupid mistake was made but the consequences are that in doing so you gave the DUP enough ammunition to use for the next 10 years or more. You stoked the fire and we will never hear the end of it now.
Didn’t Boris threaten to invoke it before the EU did? If the EU hadn’t scored an own goal they could have used it against him
This was a terrible mistake by the EU Commission, and von der Leyen should be held responsible but that’s not going to happen. I agree with Lisa Chambers and Brendan Howlin. Neale Richmond is right – the consequences are continuing. It took many years and lives to put that genie in the bottle via the Good Friday Agreement. There wouldn’t be the need to dial down the ‘heated rhetoric’, as Mr. Sefcovic so clumsily puts it, if the Commission was run by competent people.
That made a big, big cockup, almost criminal and they should take a good look at themselves. And they still won’t accept the Russian vaccine.
This was a major mistake by the EU. And its our backsides on the line to maintain peace on this island. Their cock-up, our @rse
To be honest if there was any honor he’d quit the job instead of waiting for someone to fire him. I hope it doesn’t end with “sorry”
Looks like it was a clerical error. No harm done – we are a very small player and are very lucky to be a member of the EU despite the departure of our nearest neighbour. Let’s make it work
The “decision” lasted for five hours. Lessons were learned. Get over it.
Part and parcel of being in a union. It’s going to become evermore integrated so stop moaning and move on. Ireland is a small member of something much larger and mistakes will be made in the pursuit of the perceived bigger picture.
Before the fanboys start I’ll head it off and state I am not anti EU, it’s a great concept. I’m merely a realist.
have your say