We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
LAST UPDATE | 10 Dec 2021
MEXICO HAS URGED Washington to rethink its migration policy after a horror road accident killed 55 people attempting to migrate in a truck on a major transit route to the United States.
Bodies draped in white sheets lined the roadside near Tuxtla Gutierrez in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas, where a truck transporting some 160 migrants – most from Central America – overturned Thursday. More than 100 people were injured.
Passengers, bleeding and with broken bones, lay in the road crying out in pain after the latest disaster to befall desperate people traveling through Mexico in search of a better life in the United States.
Thousands attempt the long, often dangerous, and expensive journey every year to escape violence and poverty in their home nations in South and Central America.
“It hurts when these things happen,” Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador said, stressing that the way to tackle migration is to resolve the despair people feel at home.
“The migration problem cannot be solved by coercive measures, but by opportunities for work and well-being. People don’t leave their villages for pleasure, they do it out of necessity,” he said.
If the United States wanted to prevent migration to its shores, added Lopez Obrador, it should invest in social programs in Central America – a matter he has discussed with Joe Biden.
But “there is slowness,” said the Mexican leader.
The victims of Thursday’s accident, authorities said, were from Guatemala, Honduras, Ecuador, the Dominican Republic and Mexico.
Most of the dead were from Guatemala, said Lopez Obrador.
“It was horrible to hear the wailing. I just thought about helping,” 18-year-old Sabina Lopez, who lives near the scene of the accident, told AFP.
The driver, who fled the scene, was allegedly speeding when he lost control of the truck.
State Governor Rutilio Escandon said the injured should get “prompt attention and assistance,” adding: “Law enforcement will determine who is responsible.”
Guatemalan President Alejandro Giammattei pledged to provide any of his countrymen with consular assistance, including help in getting back home, in a message on Twitter.
The INM will coordinate with local and federal authorities efforts “to provide consular assistance, identify bodies, cover funeral costs,” it said.
The National Institute of Migration said it was working to identify the dead, pay for funerals and help repatriate bodies. It said survivors will be allowed to stay in Mexico.
‘Don’t close your eyes’
The death toll is likely to rise, with many of the injured taken to hospital in a serious condition, according to Luis Manuel Garcia, a local civil protection official.
Lopez told AFP she saw a man pleading with his wounded companion.
“Don’t go to sleep, don’t close your eyes,” she recalled him saying. “Remember what you promised your mother! Hold on.”
Another nearby resident, Isaias Diaz, who arrived 15 minutes after the accident, described a ghastly scene, with “a lot of people lying around, some of them were already dead.”
Diaz said he saw “five, six children, injured … People (who had) broken legs, ribs, heads, cuts on their necks, everything.”
“The crying, the pain, the desperation. It was a very ugly atmosphere,” he said.
Broken hearts
People came spontaneously from nearby settlements Friday to place candles at the accident site, and pray.
“Our hearts are broken,” said Rocio Hernandez, a 52-year-old housewife.
The Attorney General’s Office has opened a homicide investigation, while government officials denied the truck had been allowed through a roadblock before the crash.
Guatemala’s President Alejandro Giammattei and the Vatican expressed condolences to the victims and their loved ones.
“Migratory alternatives and legal avenues are needed to avoid tragedies like this,” the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) said on Twitter.
Human traffickers commonly hide undocumented migrants in trucks bringing them from Guatemala into Mexico, from where they head north to the US border. Accidents are common.
Last month, 12 migrants died when two trucks crashed and burned in Chiapas.
In a case that shocked a country sadly accustomed to violence, 16 Guatemalans and three Mexicans were found in January burned to death inside a truck with 113 bullet holes in the state of Tamaulipas.
Migrants have told AFP that the truck journey entails hours locked up without ventilation, avoiding drinking water so as not to have to urinate. Drivers, they say, ignore pleas for fresh air.
Faced with these dangers, many migrants opt instead to join so-called caravans undertaking the long journey on foot, enduring extreme weather and other hardships, including extortion from drug gangs.
The flow of undocumented migrants has increase since Biden came to office with a promise to scrap the hardline border policies of his predecessor Donald Trump.
Mexican authorities have detected more than 190,000 migrants between January and September, three times as many as in 2020. Some 74,300 have been deported.
The United States, for its part, recorded 1.7 million people entering illegally from Mexico between October 2020 and September, a record. Many were expelled.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
It’s not a bad country we live in
@Shaun Gallagher: unfortunately tragedies of this magnitude can happen in any country, the US, UK, France, Russia, even Ireland. RIP to all who lost their lives.
@Fr. Fintan Stack: usa policy and there drug addiction have distroyed South America,
Humans will no option but leave there home trying for a better life. Not the first and won’t be the last to die.
Rip to all
“There is no mystery why Ireland, US and Western Europe are good places to live. What are the benefits of democracy?
There are ways to resolve different views and conflicts peacefully.
Respect for human dignity.
The freedom to act, speak and think freely (as long as it does not stop others doing the same).
Equality before the law.
Safe and secure community.
Good government that is efficient, transparent, responsive and accountable to citizens.” RIP to unfortunate people dying in and while fleeing mismanaged states,
@Tom Molloy: where is this land you speak of?? It certainly isn’t Ireland where white collar crime is untouchable, where corruption runs freely through every state service in particular through county council planning, state job appointments where the greed of politicians knows no limit, where the homeless and the sick are bottom of the pile when it comes to aiding them directly, but the people employed to help them have massive salaries and perks this little country is very sick in my view and needs to address everything from the bottom up, where our ministers can appoint high court judges in an empty room with no civil servants present, I think we as a country need a very big prison built and I’ll just throw in the usual thieves of bankers developers and landlords.
@Tom Molloy: Well said.
@Joe Kelly:
Someone’s angry. Why so many coming here if it’s so bad?
@Joe Kelly: still, people don’t risk their lives emigrating to Guatemala, from here.
Why are they blaming America?
@Christopher Byrne: exactly , probably Mexican truck on a Mexican road in Mexico , driven by a Mexican driver. That said RIP to all
@Christopher Byrne: the US spent a lot of money causing destruction in places like Guatemala. It would be helpful if they spent more trying to help people, or if they abandoned the war on drugs that causes so much devastation. But yes, the Central American governments need to look at their own management of things.
RIP poor souls.
The welfare state was essentially a product of the ruling classes’ self interest in the early to mid 20th century: if they didn’t start protecting, i.e. feeding, the poor, then their wealth would be at risk of being overrun.
The EU has only recently begun to understand that the same holds for particularly Africa, and has launched its ‘Global Gateway’ funding programme, not only to counter the Chinese Belt and Road initiative, but also to try and bring wealth to Africans along the way – essentially to stop them from coming here, since problems are mounting while population booms. The US should probably try to do the same with regard to Latin America.
Surly Mexico should control their own borders and stop illegal migration.
@Tom O’Hanlon: they do.
Tell them they can come to Ireland to study English and get a work visa it’s much cheaper and less dangerous.
Wow that’s rich from Mexico with their crime rate and life is very cheap , their police , military and government are either terrified of the drug Lords or in cahoots with them.
@brendan o connell: true, but I’m not sure how that contradicts his point.
have your say