Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
A FORMER FIANNA Fáil TD said he had to spend €440 in taxpayers’ money to post a copy of a research report to other politicians after being told he could not circulate it through Leinster House’s internal post.
Deputy Marc MacSharry also claimed at least one of the letters sent had later been opened by Oireachtas staff and that Ireland was “deteriorating into a Marxist Republic” in an email to the Ceann Comhairle.
The saga began last July when MacSharry was trying to distribute a copy of a report he and his staff had authored on the impact of Covid-19 on mental health.
He said the work had taken six months to complete and that he had hoped to have a copy of it sent to every member of the Oireachtas.
However, after bringing the reports to Leinster House, he was told that such material could not be freely distributed without the permission of individual party whips.
In his letter to the Ceann Comhairle, he said: “I thought how ridiculous is that? Naturally, I would expect a code of conduct to prevent unscrupulous members seeking to raise money or sell tickets by way of the internal mailing system.
“But when it’s important research I thought in the interest of basic common sense, and the reality that those elected here have an actual mandate that maybe we might be allowed share research on mental health. Clearly not!”
He said it would have taken far too long to contact all the individual whips including representatives for “god knows how many other pop-up de facto parties”.
MacSharry then detailed how he had gone to his office and affixed prepaid postage stamps from Leinster House stationary onto his “plain A4 envelopes”.
He said this had probably cost the taxpayer around €440 in postage, not to mention the costs involved in having the letters brought to a mailing centre, only to be immediately returned to Leinster House.
MacSharry then said not to be “outdone by yesterday’s stupidity”, he discovered a green crate full of his letters at the enquiries reception of the building the following day.
He said they had not been distributed and wrote that he could see “one of them at least had been opened”.
When he asked an usher about this, MacSharry said he was told: “No we have not opened any of them YET [his emphasis] Deputy, we have to wait for the head usher.”
MacSharry said he had been 19 years in the Oireachtas and had witnessed first-hand the “deterioration of the standing and treatment of members”.
He wrote: “The fact that our post is now being pre-read and subject to an approval process… to determine whether it can be delivered is a serious cause for concern to me.
Sadly, I have believed for some time that as a nation we are well on our way to deteriorating into a Marxist Republic and now when one considers that members’ correspondence to other members must be subject [to] an approval process by Houses of the Oireachtas staff without my knowledge not to mention the wider nonsense described above is truly alarming.
In a concluding note, MacSharry said if the matter was not resolved, he would seek legal advice or share details of his claims with the media.
The Ceann Comhairle’s response
Within an hour, Ceann Comhairle Seán Ó Fearghaíl responded to say he had read the letter with “surprise and anger”.
He said politicians should be facilitated to circulate correspondence to fellow members and that he was “appalled” at any suggestion that mail had been opened.
“It is not necessary for you to threaten the media on me as this is a matter I am happy to deal with,” wrote the Ceann Comhairle.
In another email later that day, Ó Fearghaíl confirmed there was a policy in place around circulation of post internally but that he felt it should be re-examined.
The Ceann Comhairle also said that there had been a delay to post that day and that he regretted any convenience.
Ó Fearghaíl added: “It has also been confirmed by the Superintendent that ushers do not open any post delivered and that they treat post, and all communications, with utmost confidentiality.”
Asked about the records, an Oireachtas spokeswoman said there was no procedure in place for post to be opened.
She said: “The Houses of the Oireachtas Commission has not made any change to the current system and protocol for the management of internal post of members.”
MacSharry said: “I got the research paper printed, and even bought blank envelopes, so I could put it in pigeonholes for my colleagues. So, they told me I had to post it.
The next day, there they were sitting in a big crate. One of them on the top had been opened. I remain unhappy about the whole process and how members of the Oireachtas are subservient to process and procedures that are wrong.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Great idea – similar laws in other countries. Should give people the right amount of time in between jobs to find their feet.
Or, maybe we could introduce a system of universal healthcare so that healthcare is accessible and affordable for everyone, and not just those who can afford insurance!
A yrs health insurance every 18 months from now on then
@Misanthrope: I take a break of 13 weeks every year when it comes up for renewal and I do not lose cover or waiting time.
You are allowed 13 weeks to shop about
@ryan3939: I should too but couldn’t be arsed. Going to start doing it now.
@ryan3939: How can you not lose cover if you take that 13 week break ? Do you mean that the insurance company will honour anything within those 13 weeks even if you haven’t paid you renewal ?
@Nosmo King: No, the current system is that, if you cancel a policy from today, you have 13 weeks from today to take up a policy again, before being slapped with waiting periods as a new customer.
So, if you cancel today, and in a month you find out that you need surgery soon, you can call up, set up a policy from the date of the call, and continue on as if nothing happened.
you can also backdate that 13 weeks if you want, but you do have to pay for the time.. which is fine, if you needed cover during the 13 weeks, but if you didn’t, then just setting up from the date of the call is a good option.
@Mirabelle Stonegate: Thanks for that. I’m surprised that insurance companies of all businesses allow such an anomaly to exist.
@Nosmo King: I’d say they would say you knew about whatever illness it was and that it was a pre-existing condition so not covered, so basically you don’t have cover for the 13wks your not paying for
@Alison Sheppard: if you’ve completed your waiting periods your free and clear on that score.
@Nosmo King: Np, i spent 6 years in health insurance. This is something that was set out by the likes of the health inurance authority, in order to be fair to health insurance holders
That stamp duty is 444 per adult and 148 per child. 1184 for the typical 1 adult 2 kid family. Ridiculous really
@lavbeer: it’s disgraceful how much of it goes straight to the government. If the tax on the cost of the policies was reduced or removed, health insurance might be more affordable to most.
@lavbeer: but will the saving REALLY be passed on – it rarely is! Remains to be seen.
@cars: For the government health levy (this is the 444, rather than the separate lifetime community rating levy), most of that money actually goes to VHI.
The health levy goes into a pot, and is then divvied up between the insurers. VHI gets something like 80% of the pot, based on how many older (over 65) members they have, and the remainder is split between Laya and Irish Life Health.
@Mirabelle Stonegate: yea it does but it’s up to 50% of my premium which now generally is worthless.
@lavbeer: Totally agree. Its just under 50% for me, and the kicker is that i am with irish life health.. Yet i am still paying vhi a substantial amount, in essence.
The levy was introduced and set out this way, because of the fact that vhi was previously fulky government owned.
Nice to see some bits and pieces coming our way for a change.
What happens if you get sick during the break
@Dave barrett: you won’t have cover if your on a break, but means when you restart you won’t have waiting period again
Say what you will about our health service but our Health Insurance market is actually regulated quite fairly all things considered.
@ForeverFeel1ng: Is that why it goes up every year and is that why the insures never question a hospital bill which is mainly makey uppy in the first place? People in wards being charged for private rooms etc, that kind of regulation?
have your say