We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
MARY LOU MCDONALD has brushed off suggestions that attending a dinner event in Sydney where a ‘Gold Table’ is on sale for upwards of €2,000 might send the wrong message back home, telling The Journal it’s not a Sinn Féin event.
The Sinn Féin leader is in Australia for a whistle stop tour of Sydney, Melbourne and Canberra this week.
The Sydney dinner, co-hosted by the Irish Australian Chamber of Commerce, which is organising a series of events with McDonald, as well as the TCD Alumni Sydney chapter was in the format of fireside “in conversation” chat with McDonald where she discussed the pandemic, Brexit, and Ireland’s position in the world.
Speaking exclusively to The Journal prior to the event outside the venue on a 100-year-old revamped wooden pier in Sydney, McDonald was unfazed by a question about the event fees, where tickets started at €140 for individuals and €1,400 for tables.
“I’ve been invited by the Trinity alumni and the Irish Australian Chamber of Commerce. I’m delighted to be here in that capacity. It’s not my event. It’s their event and, as I think you can see from the people going in and out … they’re a very regular bunch of people.”
The Journal previously reported that a spokesperson for Sinn Féin said that the party “will not be receiving any income from the tour”.
“It is to engage with the Irish community in Australia, with political representatives and with businesses and trade unions on issues in Ireland; north and south,” the spokesperson said.
Chair of the TCD Alumni Sydney Chapter Eithne McSweeney has also stated that the ticket price covers the cost of the event and that neither the alumni group nor the Chamber would make a profit.
Tánaiste Leo Varadkar previously criticised plans for the dinner in the Dáil , saying that McDonald would be “clinking” glasses with Trinity alumni who are co-hosting the event.
During a speech at the National Press Club of Australia in Canberra yesterday, McDonald made a rallying call to tradespeople, who she said were forced to live Ireland during the recession, to return home.
"To those young Irish people in Australia who want to come home: I want you to know that we are working hard to change things for you, that we WILL change things for you, and we will make Ireland the home that you deserve." – @MaryLouMcDonald pic.twitter.com/UK89Cr31is
— Sinn Féin (@sinnfeinireland) July 20, 2022
Speaking to The Journal about her comments she said she recognised that lots of Irish people choose to come to Australia and build their lives there.
“And that’s great, and we’re very proud of that contribution to Australian society. But I’m also aware there is a whole set of people who felt that they had no option but to leave and who want to go home but who currently feel that they can’t.
“The promise I have made is that we will work very, very hard to change things so that they can come home. I believe this is all about choice. And on one level, of course, people want to travel for adventure, for experience and all of that’s great stuff, but nobody should ever feel forced out or that they are prevented from coming home.”
On the wider issue, there’s huge global demand now for trades and for professions. In Ireland, we train the best of the best, we have outstanding skills and education and a work ethic like no other.
“And, yes, we need to harness that talent at home because we need to build Ireland,” she said.
Separate, to her attendance at the event hosted by the Sydney Trinity Alumni association and Irish Australian Chamber of Commerce, McDonald also attended a series of events with the Irish community, trade union leaders in Sydney, as well as members of the New South Wales Parliament.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Another great article from rory.keep up exposing this government for what it really is
@reginald: The wool has been pulled from around the eyes of the electorate thanks to honest opinions like Rory’s being given a platform to educate us on how we have been taken for fools for years by FFG. Thanks for posting this article, Journal.
@reginald: Rory Hearne … well done – representing every grandparent, parent of kids LockedOut, on Rack Rents , and at risk of eviction.
@reginald: Is Hearne not ex PBP?
@reginald: “The psychology of military incompetence was the subject of an excellent study by Norman Dixon; less has been written about the psychology of political incompetence as a general phenomenon. We can all readily think of individual incompetent politicians. But can we identify general forms of political malpractice in the field of disaster preparedness and mitigation?
Five categories come to mind:
- Failure to learn from history
- Failure of imagination
- Tendency to fight the last war or crisis
- Threat underestimation
- Procrastination, or waiting for a certainty that never comes
This is partly a problem of incentives. Leaders are rarely rewarded for what they did to avoid disasters — for the non-occurrence of a disaster is rarely a cause for celebration and gratitude — and more often are blamed for the pain of the prophylactic remedies they recommended.”
Ireland has been pimped out since the financial crash.
@Patrick Corr: Given we’ve now seen the revelations that Housing Minister Darragh O’Brien had personally invested in vulture/cuckoo funds it shows you where these people’s true hearts lie.
Great article Dr Rory, keep the pressure on the government.
Depressing reading. We have the FFG mafia whose members are some of the biggest landlords in the state in charge of this issue. I suppose when you’re in charge of the cookie jar, you’re going to raid it.
There is a total and utter disconnect between our overpaid politicians and the ordinary person. Varadkar is a poster boy for that particular fact.
Next election the FFG cartel needs to be wiped out. End of…..
@In fairness now…: I just wish there was an election tomorrow
@In fairness now…: Don’t forget, FFG did some sneaky gerrymandering of the vote to keep SF out and keep power for themselves. The electorate has not forgotten.
@In fairness now…: you will get what you deserve when your knights in shining armour (SF) get into power next time. Houses for everyone in the audience! United Ireland and Dana winning the euro vision again!
@In fairness now…: you will get what you deserve when your knights in shining armour (SF) get into power next time. Houses for everyone in the audience! United Ireland and Dana winning the euro vision again!
@In fairness now…: you will get what you deserve when your knights in shining armour (SF) get into power next time. Houses for everyone in the audience! United Ireland and Dana winning the euro vision again!
@Tim Thethird O’Hanrahan: You are obviously one of those ‘I have my house so I’m alright Jack’ types.
@Fr. Fintan Stack: No, he’s worse than that. Even with the taste in his mouth after having his tongue firmly stuck up the rear end of his local FFG TD, he still doesn’t give a fook about anyone else but himself.
Says a lot about our print media and rte that they never highlight the facts about exactly why our governments pander to investment funds as Rory has done in last weeks article and this one today.
Another incredible article Rory. Seriously this is what happens when you give absolute power to Teachers and Doctors. Countries should be run by Economists and People like yourself who know what they’re talking about. Not people who go to training school for spin and how to avoid answering a question. A bunch of educated professional debaters. You have the sense to see what’s going on and know how to change it, so why haven’t we more people like you in the position these politicians are in. They have no foresight. With someone of your knowledge and common sense in the housing department in government this sham would never have happened.
If the FFG lot with their asleep under a tree green friends told me the sky was blue, id have to go outside and double check. The stench of panic is setting in especially around the FF ranks, they know a wiping out Will come in the next election over this mess, not so much FG as their base support already live in mansions and ivory towers and wouldn’t know what a struggle to get a mortgage even looked like.
I fully support this initiative and don’t see how anyone wouldn’t (unless they are part of one of these funds). I see too many friends and colleagues my age and older stuck in a hellish loop of renting and trying to save.. I was lucky I moved early as would never get a mortgage now. Still in negative equity from 2008 but the mortgage is reasonable and we’ve a house over our heads. Like most people with a house- there but for the grace of God go I. If I were to apply on average wage now, like I did then I wouldn’t have a hope. So sorry to everyone who is stuck. This country has failed you. I hope it changes as a result of this.
Head ready to pop with rage and frustration
Can I just say also that a traditional private landlord will pay out well over 100K to the State over the lifetime of a typical 300K mortgage in tax on rental tax income and in addition stamp duty on purchase and CGT on sale of the asset? Any profit the landlord makes will be spent in the Irish economy as most are domiciled at home.
The new breed of institutional investors pay negligible income and CGT tax. They are instead taxed on dividends to which many of the pension fund investors are exempt anyway. As many of the funds are Canadian or otherwise foreign in origin this results in a significant net outflow of money from the State.
@Sean: paying tax does not build houses… ffs its not all about the tax take ….
@Mike O’Flaherty: I don’t Sean’s complaint isn’t necessarily about the tax take (but it is LOL), it’s about how FFG, labour and the greens have bent over backwards to facilitate vulture funds who are just taking money out of the Irish economy while at the same time screwing Irish businesses.
@Harry Power: I wouldn’t say taxing landlords at similar rates to PAYE workers is screwing Irish businesses. However not taxing these cuckoo funds is definitely screwing the Irish public.
The government see rent as money well spent and the lack of home owners gives them massive _____ (fill in the blank) *great article
Another great sorely needed contribution by Dr Hearne to the public discourse on the most important issue – nothing compares – brought to you by the Journal. We might actually get some real action if we all get in behind this campaign and support each other against the absentee landlords – The land league 2.0 – where the people come together and support each other against the landlords in and out of government
Didn’t read the article though.
I’m hoping the penny has finally dropped. I’ve a home paid for and am well over the hill (76) but it still makes my blood boil .
I can’t understand how people tolerate being made fools , paying some of highest rents in the world . And continuing to vote in the same weak politicians .
When you get to my age you’d better have plenty of assets
The entire philosophy informing housing policy in this country is deeply flawed because it treats housing as an economic asset and commodity instead of a social and societal necessity.
This policy has emerged and been developed by successive governments since the late seventies and reflects the philosophy of Fianna Fáil in particular, which under the leadership of Jack Lynch and his successor Charles Haughey seemed to believe that everything was for sale and social justice was a religious theory and had no place in real world policy making.
The only areas of policy and life which require intervention of state are; Health, Education, Housing and security and should never, in any circumstances be handed over to commercial interests, but in Ireland we have followed the opposite policy .
Zero balance in this article, sorry I’m not jumping on this bandwagon, too many like Rory who think the decisions are easy. Get out there Rory put yourself forward as a candidate in the next election and bring the magic wand. Seriously folks – very disappointed to see such an unbalanced article. Please set out pros and cons – don’t just gloss over the hard bits and keep going for goodness sake!
@MB: Rory is highlighting the issue and making it visible. While I agree it is easier said than done, and easy to point the finger, at least it is pointing in the right direction. Who else should fix this issue but Government? To say that Rory should run for office and wave the magic wand is childish. One person cannot fix these issues, it will only change with a change in Government policy, and articles like this to shine a light and embarrass them into it it seems. Well done Rory, keep up the good work (From a lucky homeowner, worried about my childrens future)
@MB: please enlighten us with the “cons” of his suggestions. And by the way, opinions usually are 1 sided….that’s why they’re opinions. His opinion piece, states the facts of government policy and what believes would be better policy. Experts should inform decision, they don’t need to be the decision makers. Your criticism of him for not getting elected is a straw man argument, and quite ridiculous when you scratch the surface.
@mark d: with respect Mark, I believe a lot of issues such as this are much more complex than can be set out in a couple of paragraphs. I don’t disagree with the ideology of what Rory is targeting but in practice most of these issues are exrtremely difficult to get right. I don’t appreciate the oversimplified solutions put forward and feel they fuel a mob mentality. I think all parties in government have a duty to make sensible proposals that take a balanced perspective – right now keeping capital invested in supplying housing in the country is an important factor that I don’t think should be over simplified. If the left wish to make sensible suggestions I think put the solutions forward, but think through the steps and unintended consequences carefully.
@HectorPickaxe: thanks Hector, I don’t disagree with you but I do believe it’s important to provide balance, having read Rory s article it would appear to me that there is a very easy solution that is being overlooked, which is not the case. I always read articles and try to learn something but didn’t learn anything form this unfortunately. I’m sure Rory s intentions are well meant but I see somebody who is an academic – if a mistake is made here and the capital heads for the hills we need to consider the consequences of that, I think that’s an important point not to be overlooked.
@MB: So if I pay for an airline ticket and the operator drops me to the wrong destination 5 hours late, is the only way to have it sorted to become a pilot myself? We pay governments to manage this country.
So if there is zero balance, we have heard one side, now give us the other side?
@Fr. Fintan Stack: the other side of the argument is relatively simple, push too hard and the only capital that is financing the supply of housing could shift. I believe the funds should be paying tax and that they shouldn’t be buying product that otherwise would not be supplied however we need to carefully craft the rules to ensure we don’t completely banish this form of capital out of the market. As I said I’m not against what Rorys ideology is pointing toward it’s just that we need to be very careful about how we navigate to get there as the unintended consequences could have a serious impact on housing supply.
@MB: there is nothing simplified about his proposals. The crux of his argument is that government policy is not working. We have objective evidence that this is the case. This isn’t a left or right or centre issue. This is an issue for all people living in Ireland, especially for future generations. Did you ask the question of the unintended consequences when governments moved from building social housing to HAP and RAS schemes?
@MB: Absolutely has to be carefully thought through. I’m sure nobody on a comments section has all the answers. I was commenting on your opening contribution. And yes, we don’t want to drive out finance but the government seem to be depending on only one stream of finance up to now. There are a number of financial and practical solutions put forward by Rory that I don’t believe this government have seriously looked at never mind tried to implement. For that I condemn them.
@MB: how would you explain the fact that in the poverty striken 1940′s and ’50′s the governments of the day were able to build between 30 and 50 thousand social houses a year. The answer is that they weren’t afflicted by a ideology which facilitates greed and corruption.
@Brendan Greene: that is true but the Government sold off most of the council housing for pennies in the pound during the 70s and 80s. This was a vote getter unfortunately it created problems down the line as the State then had to approach private landlords. It is somewhat ironic people saying the State could build all these houses as much of the Government owned and maintained social housing is in disrepair.
@Sean: God forbid the state selling off council houses to its citizens at a bargain price. Better to pour billions in to paying private landlord mortgages through HAP.
@Sean: firstly, the sell off was a bad idea following Margaret Thatcher’s example. The neglect of maintenance is driven by the same ideology rather than incompetence.
It’s a choice our governing parties have made.
@Sean: NAMA sold off billions of euro worth of property to the vultures for cents in the euro which made no economic sense whatsoever as those homes would have gone a long way to creating a balanced property market whereby young people could afford to buy or rent at reasonable prices compared to the monster that has now been created in the Irish housing market.
@MB: really ..the left should think through unintended consequences???? Shouldn’t every politician think through unintended consequences…. any half decent mid level manager can tell you that …we haven’t one experienced manager in power
@MB: Why don’t YOU set out the pros and cons? Why wait for somebody else to do the work for you. All smoke and no fire.
Rory Hearne – well done. You have the support of every grandparent, parent and their kids, Locked Out, Rent Raped, and at risk of Eviction.
“Housing is the battle of OUR generation. Don’t be silenced or fooled by Government inaction. Now is the time to stand up and take ‘street’ action. Angry No – Furious, bloody sure of it …
https://my.uplift.ie/petitions/stop-investors-buying-our-homes
https://www.change.org/p/irish-referendum-on-family-home-special-status
Who cares who owns the property, the fact that people believe property has that much fundamental value is the problem.
@Tom Fearon: Well anything thats “rare” in the world is valuable, like gold… we need a supply of suitable sustainable housing and not just big mansions down the country
I don’t know what exactly is meant by a social and affordable home,the author states its somewhere around 250 grand,builders will tell you that figure is not an economic figure to build a house in Ireland even a modest one,labour and materials costs are soaring due to shortages with the government state taxes a whopping 33% of build,if he means housing should be built at a loss subsidised by the taxpayers that is not a viable long term option either,as far back as I can remember housing has always been a major problem not just in this country and like the HSE nobody has ever got to grips with either..
FIANNA FÁIL’s Darragh O’Brien and Micheál Martin failed to back the ‘Affordable Housing and Fair Mortgage Bill’ as drafted by the Master of the High Court, Ed Honohan, back in 2018, and taken to second stage in the Dáil by John McGuinness – which would have prevented today’s Housing and Distressed Debt crisis… #vultureculture
Wish it could be so simple, obvious, and painless, Rory, and if it was so, then previous governments with Labour coalition partners would have done so long ago. It’s not simply supply and demand. It’s also where I want to live. I can easily get public housing or private housing in Leitrim but I want to live near my parents in Ballymun but there’s not much supply there and the rents are too high or I am competing with students at DCU. Home ownership is a Thatcherite dream. Look at how other countries e. g. Germany, prioritize renting over ownership. Ireland cannot live forever beyond its means.
Rory Herne is becoming our very own Thomas Pipette. A sound grasp of a complex situation and a will to try change. The question of land value and the Justice Kenny report (1974) must be kept in mind. Last be not least if you want to build tens of thousands of affordable homes….. first build a factory. WIth our computer literate Architects. High quality beautiful homes can be produced quickly. Imagine trying to build motor cars the way we build houses…. keep up the good work Dr.
Fergus Quinlan FRIAI.ret.
Burrin
Co. Clare
And we should not be fooled by your simplistic approach either
a brilliant piece, Cant wait for the straw to come.
Well done Rory keep up the good work
have your say