Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
WELCOME TO POLICY Matters, a series from The Journal that takes a deep dive into the ideas and solutions proposed by Ireland’s politicians on some of the biggest issues of the day.
As part of the series, The Journal sits down with different spokespeople from across Ireland’s political parties to take a deeper look at what they believe needs to be done across areas like housing, health, the environment and childcare.
Last time around, we spoke to Fine Gael’s John Cummins who told us that there is “no question” that homelessness remains the biggest challenge in housing.
This week, we sat down with People Before Profit’s foreign affairs spokesperson Gino Kenny to discuss his party’s stance on Ireland’s record on the international stage and his view of the biggest foreign policy issues facing the country.
———
PEOPLE BEFORE PROFIT’S Foreign Affairs spokesperson takes umbrage to the idea that his party is a eurosceptic one.
“I’m not sure I would use that term,” Kenny said.
In his view it is a term that has been captured by the far-right.
“We’ve been very euro-critical on a number of issues,” he said.
Indeed, the party, which has representatives in Northern Ireland, supported Britain leaving the EU and campaigned for a ‘Lexit’ (left-wing Brexit) in the run up to the 2016 referendum.
On the People Before Profit website you’ll find references to the “imperial agenda” of EU leaders and Brussels’ desire to “push neoliberalism”.
But Kenny said while he isn’t anti-EU, he is against the direction the EU is heading in.
“Most people in Ireland would be supportive of the European Union, that’s fact. And if there was a referendum to leave the European Union it would fail,” Kenny said.
“I would say I’m pro-European, you know, but I’m not pro-European in terms of the European Union and the direction of the European Union.”
Kenny said this comes down to his view that the EU is a “corporate entity” rather than one focused on social advancement.
He suspects that anti-EU sentiment is growing somewhat in Ireland but that this can be categorised in different ways, with people who are perhaps anti-EU for immigration reasons on one side, and people who are anti-EU for reasons relating to its capitalist nature on another.
“The European Union is pro-market, it’s pro-capitalist. People Before Profit would like to see less of all those things and more of a socialist project where European states are run on the basis of need, rather than a capitalist and consumerist model,” Kenny said.
Does this mean People Before Profit would like to see Ireland leave the EU?
“I don’t think that’s where we are at,” Kenny said.
“I don’t think the public would be on the side of Ireland leaving the European Union.”
For now, People Before Profit wants to engage in the European system.
Despite having no previous electoral success at European level, the party plans to run a candidate in the Dublin constituency next May and possibly a second candidate outside of Dublin too.
But Kenny is tight-lipped on who these candidates will be, saying “nothing has been finalised yet”.
When it comes to foreign affairs, the ongoing situation in Israel and Gaza is unsurprisingly top of Kenny’s lists of concerns.
Next week, he and party colleague Bríd Smith TD were to travel to Egypt as part of a convoy to the Rafah crossing where they hoped to attempt to press the Egyptian authorities to allow more aid to pass through to Gaza. That trip has now been postponed.
People Before Profit supported both the Sinn Féin and Social Democrats’ motions last week to refer Israel to the International Criminal Court and expel the Israeli ambassador to Ireland.
Kenny said he was disappointed but not surprised that the motions did not pass but noted the strong public support for both motions.
“I’ve never seen the amount of emails that came into the Oireachtas, it was incredible. The only kind of parallel that I’ve seen in my time here was the situation with the Mother and Baby Homes and that was a fraction of [the emails we got],” he said.
People Before Profit has been at the forefront of demonstrations held in support of Palestine, with this weekend being the sixth weekend in a row where thousands plan to take to the streets of Dublin.
Kenny said to his mind it is comparable to the anti-war sentiment that existed in 2003 around the Iraq war. He noted that these pro-Palestine marches have drawn engagement from people who wouldn’t normally go to protests but who feel particularly angry about the situation.
“Going out and protesting and marching, it’s not going to stop the war, but [people] feel like they’re doing something and that’s the dynamic that’s at play at the moment,” he said.
On where the situation goes next, Kenny said a ceasefire has to be the next step but beyond that he has lost faith that a two-state solution is achievable.
“Most Palestinians would accept that a two-state solution is just not possible.
“There needs to be a one-state solution where people just can live together. Now, that seems very simplified. But I think that is the only solution where people can live together,” Kenny said.
The Dublin Mid-West TD said while there was no justification for Hamas’ brutal killing of approximately 1,200 Israeli people on 7 October, the attack needs to be viewed in the context of the history of Palestine.
“You have to give it context because otherwise the whole picture is distorted,” he said.
“Palestinians, particularly people in Gaza, have been living under blockade for the last 16 years. It’s an open prison. And when you do that to a cohort of people, people will do things that me and you will never agree with.
“I’m not justifying the seventh of October, but when you brutalise people so, so much, people will do things that I don’t agree with or no rational person would agree with,” Kenny said.
Speaking about Ireland’s performance in the global arena in general terms, it’s Kenny’s view that the country “punches above its weight” when it comes to things like international aid.
He said Ireland is seen internationally as neutral and an honest broker.
“Our history can be shared with a lot of countries in the world in relation to our post-colonial past.
“We have huge empathy in relation to those that have been oppressed and those that have fled from famine and those that are fleeing from poverty,” Kenny said.
“We have a unique position, because of our history. And I think our future is that, as a people we try to help address injustice, not only in Ireland, but internationally,” he added.
Bringing the conversation back to Palestine, Kenny said this is why Ireland should do more to be a leader on pushing for a ceasefire and peace.
He referred to comments made by Taoiseach Leo Varadkar in the Dáil this week when he said that Ireland would lose influence by going too far out on a limb in relation to sanctions on Israel.
“This is the moment to be out on a limb,” Kenny said.
He pointed to Ireland being one of the first countries in the world in 1987 to introduce legislation to ban goods from apartheid South Africa.
“Ireland was a leader in relation to that. So we can be a leader again,” Kenny said.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Thinking of little Emily Hand who had her ninth birthday yesterday while being held captive in Gaza.
The people of Ireland want you home Emily.
@Tommy Haze: hopefully little Emily is alive and will be reunited with her loving family soon, unlike the 5000 little angels that will never see another birthday.
@Peter Murray: spot on.
Not that I would agree with PBP on much but we should be critical of the EU and we should of course question some of their motives behind legislation that gets passed and what countries benefit the most from it, particularly as most of this legislation is dictated by the unelected bureaucratic arm that is the commission which has scarily ascended to almost total power within Europe over the last 10 to 15 years. Our own countries sovereignty is almost non existent now particularly when it comes to climate policy where the really big industrial polluters like France, (Britain once upon a time) and Germany export a large portion of their carbon footprint with emission laws they set to suit themselves to make them look better and penalise countries like ourselves whose footprint in reality is tiny and we have to suck it up and pay taxes for their transgressions.
The Palestinian civilians in Gaza who were told to move south for refuge are now being told to flee the south for a new upcoming relentless bombing campaign by Israel,
Did everyone see the before and after satellite pics of Gaza, shocking.
Where are they supposed to go now?
@KTH: They want to push them out into the Sanai, they have drawn up plans for a tent city but they are finding resistance from Egypt.
I’m proud to live in a country that has empathy for all people suffering war regardless of race or religion. Gino seems to have a good understanding of what is at the root of the problems in the middle east. US/UK/EU imperialism, unrestricted free market greed and a consistent drive for interminable economic growth are pushing the world towards war and ecological disaster. We cannot go on exploiting vulnerable parts of the world in order to satisfy our inflated expectations of what it means to live a comfortable life. It’s just not sustainable.
The EU has evolved from its founding principles to become a compliant vassal of the US/NATO war machine, the lack of condemnation from the EU and European politicians of the slaughter and ethnic cleansing going on in Gaza is shocking.
The EU commission was specifically put in place to override democratic control of all major decisions, the people put into top positions are carefully chosen to be weak compliant careerists than can be trusted to toe the line.
The rot set in because of a culture of compliance and a refusal to question what direction the EU was heading in, this allied to the corrupting influence of lobbyists and think tanks has created a dangerous undemocratic monstrosity than enjoys a cultlike devotion from its most devoted followers and anyone that asks questions is demonised as a sceptic, extremist or hard right or left lunatic.
If you support the EU today you support the slaughter of children and ethnic cleansing (make no mistake what’s happening in Gaza is well planned ethnic cleansing) and you also support increased militarization and war mongering.
The EU was a great idea but the refusal to question and hold power to account will lead to disaster.
Lets not kid ourselves, had it not been for membership of the EU the country would be a bigger cesspit than it is.
@AnthonyK: so you hate your country do you?
@AnthonyK: I’m sick of all you no hopers calling this country a cesspit. Try living in other parts of the world. You have no idea how good you have it.
@Robbie K; @Disassociated Follower: I love my country. My point is, had it not been for the EU we would be as corrupt as other parts of the world are.
Our history even shows a European dimension. Previous rebellions always seemed to require assistance from European nations.
So, yes, I love my country. But I am not a scoundrel.
have your say